"How sick one gets of being "good," how much I should respect myself if I could burst out and make everyone wretched for twenty-four hours; embody selfishness"
About this Quote
Goodness, in Alice James's hands, reads less like virtue and more like a chronic illness: a regimen of restraint that curdles into nausea. The line snaps with the private violence of someone trained to be manageable. "How sick one gets" isn't metaphor; it's the body reporting on a moral performance that has become physically intolerable. James makes "good" a suffocating costume, and the scare quotes do the real work: goodness here is not an inner ethic but a social role, enforced and rewarded precisely because it keeps the wearer quiet.
The most startling pivot is her fantasy of sabotage as self-respect. Not happiness, not freedom, but "respect myself" if she could "make everyone wretched for twenty-four hours". The timeframe matters. It's not nihilism or a plan for permanent harm; it's a day pass to be difficult, to claim the one power routinely denied to "good" women of her class: the right to be disruptive without apology. "Embody selfishness" is phrased like an artistic or theatrical assignment, suggesting she has spent years embodying the opposite for an audience.
Context sharpens the sting. James, the brilliant, chronically ill sister of William and Henry James, lived in a world where female intellect and anger were treated as embarrassing weather: best kept indoors. Her diary becomes a pressure valve, letting cynicism and desire leak onto the page. The quote works because it refuses the sentimental narrative of sainthood. It doesn't ask to be admired for endurance; it wants, briefly and scandalously, to be allowed to break character.
The most startling pivot is her fantasy of sabotage as self-respect. Not happiness, not freedom, but "respect myself" if she could "make everyone wretched for twenty-four hours". The timeframe matters. It's not nihilism or a plan for permanent harm; it's a day pass to be difficult, to claim the one power routinely denied to "good" women of her class: the right to be disruptive without apology. "Embody selfishness" is phrased like an artistic or theatrical assignment, suggesting she has spent years embodying the opposite for an audience.
Context sharpens the sting. James, the brilliant, chronically ill sister of William and Henry James, lived in a world where female intellect and anger were treated as embarrassing weather: best kept indoors. Her diary becomes a pressure valve, letting cynicism and desire leak onto the page. The quote works because it refuses the sentimental narrative of sainthood. It doesn't ask to be admired for endurance; it wants, briefly and scandalously, to be allowed to break character.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Alice
Add to List





