"Humanism was not wrong in thinking that truth, beauty, liberty, and equality are of infinite value, but in thinking that man can get them for himself without grace"
About this Quote
Simone Weil takes a scalpel to the modern self-image: the idea that we can climb, by our own moral athleticism, into a world where truth and justice simply arrive as earned achievements. She grants humanism its best claim, even flatters it: truth, beauty, liberty, equality really are worth everything. Then she flips the knife. The error is not aspiration but self-sufficiency.
The line works because it’s built as a trapdoor. “Not wrong... but” lets the reader settle into agreement before the floor drops out under “man can get them for himself.” Weil isn’t scolding people for wanting the good; she’s diagnosing the pride baked into secular progress narratives, where history is a staircase and humanity is its own savior. “Grace” here is doing heavy, abrasive work. It’s not a sentimental religious add-on; it’s her name for what can’t be manufactured by willpower, policy, or enlightened education alone. The best things, she implies, are not products. They are gifts, eruptions, visitations - and our job is attention, receptivity, self-emptying.
Context sharpens the critique. Weil lived through the 1930s and early 1940s, watching grand human projects - revolutionary politics, technocratic planning, national destinies - promise emancipation and deliver mechanized cruelty. Her suspicion is that when humans try to possess the infinite, they turn it into an instrument: “truth” becomes propaganda, “equality” becomes coercion, “liberty” becomes license for the strong. Grace is the check on that conversion: a refusal to confuse moral ideals with human control, and a demand that humility precede reform.
The line works because it’s built as a trapdoor. “Not wrong... but” lets the reader settle into agreement before the floor drops out under “man can get them for himself.” Weil isn’t scolding people for wanting the good; she’s diagnosing the pride baked into secular progress narratives, where history is a staircase and humanity is its own savior. “Grace” here is doing heavy, abrasive work. It’s not a sentimental religious add-on; it’s her name for what can’t be manufactured by willpower, policy, or enlightened education alone. The best things, she implies, are not products. They are gifts, eruptions, visitations - and our job is attention, receptivity, self-emptying.
Context sharpens the critique. Weil lived through the 1930s and early 1940s, watching grand human projects - revolutionary politics, technocratic planning, national destinies - promise emancipation and deliver mechanized cruelty. Her suspicion is that when humans try to possess the infinite, they turn it into an instrument: “truth” becomes propaganda, “equality” becomes coercion, “liberty” becomes license for the strong. Grace is the check on that conversion: a refusal to confuse moral ideals with human control, and a demand that humility precede reform.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Simone
Add to List









