"Hypocrisy is not generally a social sin, but a virtue"
About this Quote
Hypocrisy gets framed as a moral failure, but Judith Martin, better known as Miss Manners, is pointing at something more uncomfortable: society often runs on small, agreed-upon fictions. In the etiquette universe, sincerity is overrated; what matters is keeping the room livable. The “virtue” here isn’t lying for personal gain, but restraining the impulse to broadcast every honest thought like it’s a public service announcement.
Martin’s intent is slyly corrective. She’s defending manners against the modern cult of authenticity, the idea that being “real” excuses being rude. Her subtext: most people don’t actually want your unfiltered truth; they want a predictable baseline of respect that lets them move through the day without constant emotional negotiation. Hypocrisy, in this framing, is the social technology of pretending you’re not irritated, not bored, not judging someone’s taste, because the alternative is a low-grade war of everyone’s immediate feelings.
The context matters: Martin wrote across decades when American culture increasingly prized confession, therapeutic candor, and “say it with your whole chest” self-expression. Etiquette, to her, isn’t aristocratic frill but democratic infrastructure. Calling hypocrisy a “virtue” is a provocation designed to rescue politeness from accusations of falseness. She’s arguing that civilization depends on selective silence and performed goodwill, not because we’re saints, but because we’re not.
Martin’s intent is slyly corrective. She’s defending manners against the modern cult of authenticity, the idea that being “real” excuses being rude. Her subtext: most people don’t actually want your unfiltered truth; they want a predictable baseline of respect that lets them move through the day without constant emotional negotiation. Hypocrisy, in this framing, is the social technology of pretending you’re not irritated, not bored, not judging someone’s taste, because the alternative is a low-grade war of everyone’s immediate feelings.
The context matters: Martin wrote across decades when American culture increasingly prized confession, therapeutic candor, and “say it with your whole chest” self-expression. Etiquette, to her, isn’t aristocratic frill but democratic infrastructure. Calling hypocrisy a “virtue” is a provocation designed to rescue politeness from accusations of falseness. She’s arguing that civilization depends on selective silence and performed goodwill, not because we’re saints, but because we’re not.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|
More Quotes by Judith
Add to List
