"I add this, that rational ability without education has oftener raised man to glory and virtue, than education without natural ability"
About this Quote
Cicero contrasts the power of innate reason with the polish of formal schooling, asserting that native capacity more often lifts people to glory and virtue than education that lacks natural ability at its core. The claim turns on a Roman distinction between ingenium and doctrina. Ingenium is the spark: quickness of mind, sound judgment, moral intuition, the capacity to grasp principles and act decisively. Doctrina is the accumulation of techniques, rules, and erudition. Schooling can refine, but it cannot breathe life into what is fundamentally inert; where ingenium is present, even minimal training can become a force for excellence.
Glory and virtue are not only public acclaim and moral rectitude; in Roman thought they are linked. Lasting glory attaches to actions shaped by reason and courage, the texture of character as well as skill. Cicero suggests that rational ability, by its own internal compass, more readily finds that path than an education that adds adornment without direction. The line also channels his broader oratorical theory. In De Oratore he insists that natural talent is indispensable and that art and practice are fruitful only when they meet a living mind. He makes a similar case in defending the poet Archias: method cannot substitute for genius.
This is not a dismissal of learning. Cicero was among the most learned Romans, and he repeatedly praises study as a source of pleasure, discipline, and civic usefulness. The point is proportionality. Education amplifies; it does not create from nothing. Where there is judgment, imagination, and moral sense, instruction produces greatness. Where these are absent, instruction risks pedantry or cleverness without goodness.
Read as a warning against credential worship, the maxim still stings. Institutions certify knowledge, not wisdom. The decisive qualities for public life remain clarity of mind, steadiness of character, and a native feel for prudence, which education may sharpen but cannot supply.
Glory and virtue are not only public acclaim and moral rectitude; in Roman thought they are linked. Lasting glory attaches to actions shaped by reason and courage, the texture of character as well as skill. Cicero suggests that rational ability, by its own internal compass, more readily finds that path than an education that adds adornment without direction. The line also channels his broader oratorical theory. In De Oratore he insists that natural talent is indispensable and that art and practice are fruitful only when they meet a living mind. He makes a similar case in defending the poet Archias: method cannot substitute for genius.
This is not a dismissal of learning. Cicero was among the most learned Romans, and he repeatedly praises study as a source of pleasure, discipline, and civic usefulness. The point is proportionality. Education amplifies; it does not create from nothing. Where there is judgment, imagination, and moral sense, instruction produces greatness. Where these are absent, instruction risks pedantry or cleverness without goodness.
Read as a warning against credential worship, the maxim still stings. Institutions certify knowledge, not wisdom. The decisive qualities for public life remain clarity of mind, steadiness of character, and a native feel for prudence, which education may sharpen but cannot supply.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List












