"I almost never try to make the audience comfortable. I wouldn't want that if I were in the audience"
About this Quote
Comfort is the enemy of attention, and Carter Burwell knows it. As a film composer, he’s paid to steer feeling in real time, yet he’s suspicious of the easiest feelings: reassurance, release, the sonic equivalent of a padded seat. Burwell’s line reads like a quiet manifesto against musical customer service. He’s not scoring to soothe; he’s scoring to sharpen.
The intent is practical as much as aesthetic. “Almost never” leaves room for tenderness, but it frames tenderness as a choice, not a default setting. Burwell’s best-known work (especially with the Coen brothers) thrives on that discipline: music that doesn’t tell you what to think, doesn’t round off the scene’s jagged edges, doesn’t hand you an emotional exit ramp. Instead it can sit slightly askew from the image, creating a productive unease. That tension is where meaning leaks in: you start scanning the scene more actively, questioning motives, hearing the silence, noticing the cruelty or absurdity that comfort would blur.
The subtext is a critique of audience management. Modern media often treats viewers like clients to be retained, nudged, and reassured. Burwell flips the power dynamic: if he were the audience, he’d resent being lulled. It’s a composer’s version of anti-handholding, an insistence that art should risk displeasing you in order to wake you up.
Context matters because film music is famously manipulative. Burwell’s stance isn’t anti-emotion; it’s anti-automation. He’s arguing for scores that keep your nervous system honest.
The intent is practical as much as aesthetic. “Almost never” leaves room for tenderness, but it frames tenderness as a choice, not a default setting. Burwell’s best-known work (especially with the Coen brothers) thrives on that discipline: music that doesn’t tell you what to think, doesn’t round off the scene’s jagged edges, doesn’t hand you an emotional exit ramp. Instead it can sit slightly askew from the image, creating a productive unease. That tension is where meaning leaks in: you start scanning the scene more actively, questioning motives, hearing the silence, noticing the cruelty or absurdity that comfort would blur.
The subtext is a critique of audience management. Modern media often treats viewers like clients to be retained, nudged, and reassured. Burwell flips the power dynamic: if he were the audience, he’d resent being lulled. It’s a composer’s version of anti-handholding, an insistence that art should risk displeasing you in order to wake you up.
Context matters because film music is famously manipulative. Burwell’s stance isn’t anti-emotion; it’s anti-automation. He’s arguing for scores that keep your nervous system honest.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Carter
Add to List
