"I always assume that democracy is the only good form of government, quite frankly, and democracy is always to be preferred"
About this Quote
There is something disarmingly blunt about Kirkpatrick’s “quite frankly”: it’s the verbal equivalent of planting a flag before the argument even begins. “I always assume” doesn’t just signal conviction; it smuggles in a worldview where democracy isn’t a hypothesis to be tested but a default setting. That move matters because it converts a contested political ideal into a kind of moral common sense. If you disagree, you’re not merely arguing policy - you’re deviating from reason itself.
As a Cold War-era diplomat, Kirkpatrick operated in a moment when “democracy” functioned as both aspiration and instrument. The line reads like reassurance to domestic audiences and allies: America knows what it stands for. But the subtext is more complicated. By insisting democracy is “always to be preferred,” she invokes an absolute that realpolitik rarely honors. That absolutism can work rhetorically because it simplifies a messy landscape of imperfect elections, fragile institutions, and strategic compromises into a clean hierarchy: democracy at the top, everything else beneath.
The intent isn’t nuanced theory; it’s permission. Permission to judge regimes quickly, to rank outcomes morally, and to justify intervention or support based on alignment with “the only good” system. The phrase “only good form” also reveals an anxiety: democracy’s legitimacy must be restated precisely because it’s perennially challenged by disorder, backlash, and the temptation of “stability” offered by strongmen. Kirkpatrick’s certainty is a diplomatic tool - and a tell.
As a Cold War-era diplomat, Kirkpatrick operated in a moment when “democracy” functioned as both aspiration and instrument. The line reads like reassurance to domestic audiences and allies: America knows what it stands for. But the subtext is more complicated. By insisting democracy is “always to be preferred,” she invokes an absolute that realpolitik rarely honors. That absolutism can work rhetorically because it simplifies a messy landscape of imperfect elections, fragile institutions, and strategic compromises into a clean hierarchy: democracy at the top, everything else beneath.
The intent isn’t nuanced theory; it’s permission. Permission to judge regimes quickly, to rank outcomes morally, and to justify intervention or support based on alignment with “the only good” system. The phrase “only good form” also reveals an anxiety: democracy’s legitimacy must be restated precisely because it’s perennially challenged by disorder, backlash, and the temptation of “stability” offered by strongmen. Kirkpatrick’s certainty is a diplomatic tool - and a tell.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jeane
Add to List










