"I always had a desire to know asylum life more thoroughly - a desire to be convinced that the most helpless of God's creatures, the insane, were cared for kindly and properly"
About this Quote
Bly frames her curiosity as almost devotional: not a tourist’s itch for the grotesque, but a “desire to be convinced” that society has kept its moral promises. That phrasing matters. She’s not assuming cruelty; she’s exposing how easy it is for polite readers to outsource conscience to institutions and then demand reassurance instead of proof. The line reads like a setup, because Bly knows what many reform stories require: you begin with faith in the system so the betrayal lands harder.
The subtext is a dare to the era’s respectable complacency. Calling the incarcerated “the most helpless of God’s creatures” borrows the language of Victorian piety, then weaponizes it. If you claim a Christian social order, she implies, your asylums should look like mercy, not punishment. By choosing “insane” without euphemism, she also signals how blunt the stakes are: these are people stripped of credibility, whose suffering can be dismissed as symptom. Her job, as she defines it here, is to restore their reality.
Context does the rest. Bly’s most famous investigation, Ten Days in a Mad-House, came from feigning illness to enter Blackwell’s Island and report conditions from inside. This sentence is the ethical alibi and the narrative engine: a journalist using her own body as evidence in a system designed to erase evidence. “Kindly and properly” sounds modest, almost bureaucratic, which is the point. She isn’t asking for sainthood, just basic care; the implication is that even that minimum is scandalously unmet.
The subtext is a dare to the era’s respectable complacency. Calling the incarcerated “the most helpless of God’s creatures” borrows the language of Victorian piety, then weaponizes it. If you claim a Christian social order, she implies, your asylums should look like mercy, not punishment. By choosing “insane” without euphemism, she also signals how blunt the stakes are: these are people stripped of credibility, whose suffering can be dismissed as symptom. Her job, as she defines it here, is to restore their reality.
Context does the rest. Bly’s most famous investigation, Ten Days in a Mad-House, came from feigning illness to enter Blackwell’s Island and report conditions from inside. This sentence is the ethical alibi and the narrative engine: a journalist using her own body as evidence in a system designed to erase evidence. “Kindly and properly” sounds modest, almost bureaucratic, which is the point. She isn’t asking for sainthood, just basic care; the implication is that even that minimum is scandalously unmet.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mental Health |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Nellie
Add to List





