"I always say that I don't want to be sentimental, that the photographs shouldn't be sentimental, and yet, I am conscious of my sentimentality"
About this Quote
Frank’s line is a tightrope walk between swagger and confession: the photographer who distrusts sentiment, then catches himself craving it. The first clause sounds like a manifesto - anti-cheese, anti-Hallmark, anti-easy feeling. In mid-century documentary photography, “sentimental” wasn’t just an aesthetic sin; it was a political one. Sentimentality implies comfort, reassurance, a world where images soothe rather than scrape. Frank built his reputation by refusing that bargain.
Then he punctures his own pose: “and yet.” The pivot matters. He isn’t admitting defeat so much as admitting awareness, which is more subversive. Frank knows that photographs are feeling-machines no matter how tough the photographer acts. The camera frames, isolates, lingers - it turns ordinary gestures into meaning. Trying to make an image without sentiment is like trying to write without tone.
The subtext is a warning about purity. Frank’s work, especially in The Americans era, is often praised for its cool distance and unsparing eye. He’s reminding you that the “unsentimental” look can itself become a style, even a performance. His honesty is in owning the contradiction: to care about people, to look hard at them, is already to risk tenderness.
Contextually, this is also a defense of ambiguity. Frank rejects the syrupy, but he refuses the opposite trap: cynicism as armor. The best photographs, he suggests, aren’t made by erasing emotion; they’re made by controlling it - letting sentiment leak in, then not letting it take over.
Then he punctures his own pose: “and yet.” The pivot matters. He isn’t admitting defeat so much as admitting awareness, which is more subversive. Frank knows that photographs are feeling-machines no matter how tough the photographer acts. The camera frames, isolates, lingers - it turns ordinary gestures into meaning. Trying to make an image without sentiment is like trying to write without tone.
The subtext is a warning about purity. Frank’s work, especially in The Americans era, is often praised for its cool distance and unsparing eye. He’s reminding you that the “unsentimental” look can itself become a style, even a performance. His honesty is in owning the contradiction: to care about people, to look hard at them, is already to risk tenderness.
Contextually, this is also a defense of ambiguity. Frank rejects the syrupy, but he refuses the opposite trap: cynicism as armor. The best photographs, he suggests, aren’t made by erasing emotion; they’re made by controlling it - letting sentiment leak in, then not letting it take over.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List




