"I am an agnostic; I do not pretend to know what many ignorant men are sure of"
About this Quote
Darrow’s line is a courtroom objection disguised as a confession. He doesn’t just announce doubt; he indicts certainty. The first clause, “I am an agnostic,” sounds modest, almost shrugging. The second clause snaps the trap shut: “I do not pretend to know what many ignorant men are sure of.” The real target isn’t faith as such, but the swaggering posture of knowledge - the kind that treats complexity as an insult and questions as weakness.
Intent matters here. Darrow was a famous defense attorney and public skeptic, a man who watched institutions use moral certainty as a weapon: against labor organizers, against defendants without power, against modern science in the Scopes “Monkey Trial” era. In that world, certainty wasn’t merely intellectual; it was procedural. It decided who was respectable, who was criminal, who was allowed to speak. By calling himself agnostic, Darrow claims the ethical high ground of intellectual restraint. By calling his opponents “ignorant,” he makes it clear restraint is not submission.
The subtext is a reversal of the usual insult. Agnosticism is often framed as evasive or wishy-washy; Darrow flips it into courage. “Do not pretend” is the key phrase: he implies that much proclaimed certainty is performance, social signaling, a bid for authority. The sentence lands because it’s calibrated to sting: it praises humility while refusing to be humble in the face of sanctimony. Darrow turns doubt into a moral stance, and certainty into a tell.
Intent matters here. Darrow was a famous defense attorney and public skeptic, a man who watched institutions use moral certainty as a weapon: against labor organizers, against defendants without power, against modern science in the Scopes “Monkey Trial” era. In that world, certainty wasn’t merely intellectual; it was procedural. It decided who was respectable, who was criminal, who was allowed to speak. By calling himself agnostic, Darrow claims the ethical high ground of intellectual restraint. By calling his opponents “ignorant,” he makes it clear restraint is not submission.
The subtext is a reversal of the usual insult. Agnosticism is often framed as evasive or wishy-washy; Darrow flips it into courage. “Do not pretend” is the key phrase: he implies that much proclaimed certainty is performance, social signaling, a bid for authority. The sentence lands because it’s calibrated to sting: it praises humility while refusing to be humble in the face of sanctimony. Darrow turns doubt into a moral stance, and certainty into a tell.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Clarence Darrow — attributed quote: "I am an agnostic; I do not pretend to know what many ignorant men are sure of." Source: Wikiquote entry "Clarence Darrow". |
More Quotes by Clarence
Add to List







