"I am as confounded by dogs as I am indebted to them"
About this Quote
Confusion and gratitude don’t usually share a sentence unless the speaker is admitting to a relationship that runs deeper than simple affection. Roger Caras, a photographer who made a career out of looking closely at animals and the people who orbit them, frames dogs as both an enigma and a moral debt. “Confounded” isn’t the cute bafflement of a pet owner watching a dog chase its tail; it suggests a genuinely unresolved puzzle: why these animals read us so well, why they attach so fiercely, why their loyalty can feel almost embarrassing in its intensity. Dogs don’t just behave; they seem to mean something, and that meaning resists tidy explanation.
Then comes the turn: “as indebted to them.” Caras isn’t claiming ownership, he’s conceding obligation. The subtext is quietly accusatory toward the human tendency to sentimentalize dogs while taking their gifts for granted. Indebtedness implies dogs have paid in advance: with companionship, protection, routine, comic relief, maybe even with the simple fact that they force us to be less sealed-off versions of ourselves. If you’ve ever walked a dog in a bad week and felt your brain re-enter your body, you know the bill has been covered.
As a photographer, Caras’s line also reads like a credo about looking: the more you study a subject, the less you can reduce it. Dogs keep slipping past our categories - pet, tool, family - and that slippage is exactly what earns them the punchline’s gravity. The joke lands because it’s true, and because it admits we’re the ones being trained.
Then comes the turn: “as indebted to them.” Caras isn’t claiming ownership, he’s conceding obligation. The subtext is quietly accusatory toward the human tendency to sentimentalize dogs while taking their gifts for granted. Indebtedness implies dogs have paid in advance: with companionship, protection, routine, comic relief, maybe even with the simple fact that they force us to be less sealed-off versions of ourselves. If you’ve ever walked a dog in a bad week and felt your brain re-enter your body, you know the bill has been covered.
As a photographer, Caras’s line also reads like a credo about looking: the more you study a subject, the less you can reduce it. Dogs keep slipping past our categories - pet, tool, family - and that slippage is exactly what earns them the punchline’s gravity. The joke lands because it’s true, and because it admits we’re the ones being trained.
Quote Details
| Topic | Dog |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Roger
Add to List






