"I am certainly not a mainstream religious man"
About this Quote
There is a special kind of American candor in “I am certainly not a mainstream religious man”: the firmness of the disclaimer paired with the softness of the self-portrait. David Ogden Stiers isn’t declaring atheism or picking a theological fight. He’s drawing a boundary line around expectations that cling to public figures, especially older, Midwestern-coded, respectably dressed character actors who often get drafted into the cultural role of “moral authority.”
The key word is “mainstream.” It’s a social marker more than a doctrinal one, implying he knows exactly what the mainstream looks like: church-as-community, faith-as-normalcy, religion as polite identity. By stepping outside it, Stiers signals independence without asking to be read as rebellious. “Certainly” does similar work: it pre-empts the interviewer’s assumptions, a gentle correction delivered with actorly precision.
Context matters because Stiers’ career (not least his long run on MASH as Charles Winchester) traded in intelligence, refinement, and a kind of skeptical civility. That persona fits a person who wants spirituality, ethics, or meaning on his own terms, not as a script handed down by tradition. For an actor whose private life was often kept carefully managed in a less-forgiving era, the line also reads as coded self-definition: a way of saying, I don’t fit the default template, and I’m done pretending I do.
It works because it’s neither confessional nor combative. It’s a refusal to perform belonging.
The key word is “mainstream.” It’s a social marker more than a doctrinal one, implying he knows exactly what the mainstream looks like: church-as-community, faith-as-normalcy, religion as polite identity. By stepping outside it, Stiers signals independence without asking to be read as rebellious. “Certainly” does similar work: it pre-empts the interviewer’s assumptions, a gentle correction delivered with actorly precision.
Context matters because Stiers’ career (not least his long run on MASH as Charles Winchester) traded in intelligence, refinement, and a kind of skeptical civility. That persona fits a person who wants spirituality, ethics, or meaning on his own terms, not as a script handed down by tradition. For an actor whose private life was often kept carefully managed in a less-forgiving era, the line also reads as coded self-definition: a way of saying, I don’t fit the default template, and I’m done pretending I do.
It works because it’s neither confessional nor combative. It’s a refusal to perform belonging.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List



