"I am indeed amazed when I consider how weak my mind is and how prone to error"
About this Quote
Descartes opens not with swagger but with a kind of calibrated self-distrust, and that’s the point. “I am indeed amazed” isn’t just modesty; it’s a dramatic beat that turns inward doubt into intellectual momentum. The sentence stages a confrontation between a brilliant mathematical mind and the unnerving fact that brilliance doesn’t immunize you against being wrong. In an era where inherited authority - scholastic tradition, Aristotelian physics, theological certainty - still claimed to explain the world, admitting “how weak my mind is” functions like a crowbar. If the mind is “prone to error,” then received wisdom is not a foundation; it’s a suspect witness.
The subtext is strategic: Descartes isn’t confessing to collapse, he’s clearing the ground. This is the emotional and rhetorical preface to his methodic doubt. By framing error as a default condition, he licenses an extreme remedy: suspend belief, inspect every assumption, keep only what survives the harshest test. The amazement is important because it makes skepticism feel less like a fashionable pose and more like a lived shock - a discovery about cognition itself.
As a mathematician, Descartes is also smuggling in an ideal. Math works because it disciplines the mind into steps that can be checked, repeated, and shared. The “weak mind” line quietly justifies importing that rigor into philosophy. It’s an argument for technique over temperament: truth won’t come from being smarter, but from building a system that can withstand your own fallibility.
The subtext is strategic: Descartes isn’t confessing to collapse, he’s clearing the ground. This is the emotional and rhetorical preface to his methodic doubt. By framing error as a default condition, he licenses an extreme remedy: suspend belief, inspect every assumption, keep only what survives the harshest test. The amazement is important because it makes skepticism feel less like a fashionable pose and more like a lived shock - a discovery about cognition itself.
As a mathematician, Descartes is also smuggling in an ideal. Math works because it disciplines the mind into steps that can be checked, repeated, and shared. The “weak mind” line quietly justifies importing that rigor into philosophy. It’s an argument for technique over temperament: truth won’t come from being smarter, but from building a system that can withstand your own fallibility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Rene
Add to List





