"I am not sincere, even when I say I am not"
About this Quote
Renard’s line is a trapdoor disguised as a confession: it turns sincerity into a hall of mirrors where every declaration carries its own alibi. “I am not sincere” sounds like the frank, cleansing admission modern audiences crave, the kind of anti-posturing that signals authenticity by refusing it. Then the second clause detonates that comfort. Even the act of self-exposure is staged; the speaker can’t deliver truth without also performing it.
The intent is less self-loathing than scalpel-sharp social observation. Fin-de-siecle France was saturated with salon manners, reputations, and the kind of moral posturing that made “candor” just another style. Renard, a master of the diary fragment and the theatrical aside, understands that sincerity is never pure speech; it’s a pose calibrated for an audience, even if the audience is your own conscience. The line works because it weaponizes logical paradox to reveal an emotional one: people want to be believed, but they also want to retain control. If you preemptively undermine yourself, you stay unpinned.
Subtext: the self is not a stable narrator. The speaker is both defendant and lawyer, testifying while cross-examining his own testimony. It’s a dramatist’s sentence because it stages conflict in miniature: the performance of honesty battling the suspicion that honesty is just another costume. Renard isn’t asking to be forgiven for duplicity; he’s insisting that the very language of virtue is compromised by the need to say it aloud.
The intent is less self-loathing than scalpel-sharp social observation. Fin-de-siecle France was saturated with salon manners, reputations, and the kind of moral posturing that made “candor” just another style. Renard, a master of the diary fragment and the theatrical aside, understands that sincerity is never pure speech; it’s a pose calibrated for an audience, even if the audience is your own conscience. The line works because it weaponizes logical paradox to reveal an emotional one: people want to be believed, but they also want to retain control. If you preemptively undermine yourself, you stay unpinned.
Subtext: the self is not a stable narrator. The speaker is both defendant and lawyer, testifying while cross-examining his own testimony. It’s a dramatist’s sentence because it stages conflict in miniature: the performance of honesty battling the suspicion that honesty is just another costume. Renard isn’t asking to be forgiven for duplicity; he’s insisting that the very language of virtue is compromised by the need to say it aloud.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Jules Renard — original French: "Je ne suis pas sincère, même quand je dis que je ne le suis pas." (see attributed listing) |
More Quotes by Jules
Add to List






