"I am, of course, aware that the ultimate solution is the ownership and control of the means of life by the whole of the people; but we are not at that stage of development as yet"
About this Quote
Larkin slips a revolution into a concession, and the sentence structure is the tell. “Of course” performs confidence and camaraderie at once: he assumes his audience already knows the “ultimate solution,” casting collective ownership not as a wild idea but as the obvious destination for anyone paying attention. It’s a neat bit of movement-building rhetoric, smuggling a maximalist horizon into what sounds like practical talk.
Then comes the pivot: “but we are not at that stage of development as yet.” On its face it’s moderation, a calming hand on the room. Underneath, it’s a strategic refusal to let immediate tactics be mistaken for ultimate aims. Larkin was a labor organizer in a country where workers were battling employers, police, and often a state apparatus aligned against them. To speak plainly about “ownership and control” is to align with socialist tradition; to add the developmental caveat is to keep the coalition intact - the radical, the cautious, the person who just wants a fair wage this week.
The phrase “means of life” is the sharper choice than “means of production.” It widens the target from factories to the whole infrastructure of survival: housing, food, transport, health, time itself. That framing turns labor politics into moral politics, implying that what’s at stake isn’t just pay packets but who gets to decide how life is lived.
His subtext is patient pressure: you may not be ready, history may not be ready, but the direction is set - and the present struggle is a rung on that ladder.
Then comes the pivot: “but we are not at that stage of development as yet.” On its face it’s moderation, a calming hand on the room. Underneath, it’s a strategic refusal to let immediate tactics be mistaken for ultimate aims. Larkin was a labor organizer in a country where workers were battling employers, police, and often a state apparatus aligned against them. To speak plainly about “ownership and control” is to align with socialist tradition; to add the developmental caveat is to keep the coalition intact - the radical, the cautious, the person who just wants a fair wage this week.
The phrase “means of life” is the sharper choice than “means of production.” It widens the target from factories to the whole infrastructure of survival: housing, food, transport, health, time itself. That framing turns labor politics into moral politics, implying that what’s at stake isn’t just pay packets but who gets to decide how life is lived.
His subtext is patient pressure: you may not be ready, history may not be ready, but the direction is set - and the present struggle is a rung on that ladder.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List








