"I believe every one of us possesses a fundamental right to tell our own story"
About this Quote
Maynard’s line plants a flag in one of literature’s most bruised battlefields: who gets to narrate a life, and at what cost. The phrasing is doing careful work. “I believe” frames the claim as moral conviction rather than legal doctrine, sidestepping courts and contracts and placing the dispute in the realm of ethics and power. “Every one of us” is democratic on its face, but it also smuggles in a rebuke: gatekeepers (families, institutions, famous exes, editors, readers hungry for scandal) routinely treat autobiography as a privilege granted to the compliant. Calling it a “fundamental right” elevates storytelling from vanity project to agency, a refusal to be reduced to someone else’s version of events.
The subtext is inseparable from Maynard’s own career, marked by public scrutiny and debates over the legitimacy of personal revelation. She knows that telling your story is rarely a solitary act; it implicates other people, sometimes uncomfortably. The sentence anticipates the predictable counterattack - that memoir is betrayal, that privacy is sacred - and answers it by shifting the center of gravity. The default assumption in many cultural arguments is that silence is the responsible choice. Maynard flips that: silence can be coerced, and coerced silence is a form of ownership.
What makes the quote effective is its calm insistence. No melodrama, no defensiveness. It’s a writer staking out territory: narrative as self-determination, especially for those whose lives have been narrated for them.
The subtext is inseparable from Maynard’s own career, marked by public scrutiny and debates over the legitimacy of personal revelation. She knows that telling your story is rarely a solitary act; it implicates other people, sometimes uncomfortably. The sentence anticipates the predictable counterattack - that memoir is betrayal, that privacy is sacred - and answers it by shifting the center of gravity. The default assumption in many cultural arguments is that silence is the responsible choice. Maynard flips that: silence can be coerced, and coerced silence is a form of ownership.
What makes the quote effective is its calm insistence. No melodrama, no defensiveness. It’s a writer staking out territory: narrative as self-determination, especially for those whose lives have been narrated for them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joyce
Add to List
