"I believe in broken, fractured, complicated narratives, but I believe in narratives as a vehicle for truth, not simply as a form of entertainment, though I love entertainment, but also a way of conveying what needs to be conveyed about the works that I care about"
About this Quote
Greenblatt’s sentence unspools like the very “broken, fractured, complicated” stories he’s defending: clauses stack, double back, correct themselves. It’s not verbal sloppiness; it’s a performed argument. He’s dramatizing a core claim of his career-long project: meaning doesn’t arrive as a clean thesis, it arrives as a lived tangle, and criticism has to honor that mess without surrendering to it.
The key move is his refusal of a false binary. Narrative, for Greenblatt, isn’t the enemy of truth (as some theory-heavy skepticism once insisted), and it isn’t mere popcorn either (as market logic would prefer). It’s a vehicle: transport with a destination. He loves entertainment, but he won’t let pleasure be the final alibi. That “though” is doing cultural work, pushing back against an academy accused of being joyless while also pushing back against a media ecosystem that treats storytelling as frictionless content.
Context matters: Greenblatt helped popularize New Historicism, which reads literature as entangled with power, ideology, and the everyday machinery of a period. “Truth” here isn’t a single moral; it’s the textured account of how people lived, justified themselves, and got trapped by their own systems. The insistence on “the works that I care about” makes the subtext personal and strategic: criticism is advocacy. He’s arguing that interpretation is not neutral scholarship but a choice to carry certain works forward, to convey what “needs to be conveyed” before culture forgets, flattens, or sells it.
The key move is his refusal of a false binary. Narrative, for Greenblatt, isn’t the enemy of truth (as some theory-heavy skepticism once insisted), and it isn’t mere popcorn either (as market logic would prefer). It’s a vehicle: transport with a destination. He loves entertainment, but he won’t let pleasure be the final alibi. That “though” is doing cultural work, pushing back against an academy accused of being joyless while also pushing back against a media ecosystem that treats storytelling as frictionless content.
Context matters: Greenblatt helped popularize New Historicism, which reads literature as entangled with power, ideology, and the everyday machinery of a period. “Truth” here isn’t a single moral; it’s the textured account of how people lived, justified themselves, and got trapped by their own systems. The insistence on “the works that I care about” makes the subtext personal and strategic: criticism is advocacy. He’s arguing that interpretation is not neutral scholarship but a choice to carry certain works forward, to convey what “needs to be conveyed” before culture forgets, flattens, or sells it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List




