"I believe that if you are elderly, physically or mentally handicapped we have an obligation too you, but if you are able-bodied, you should be working"
About this Quote
The line draws a bright moral border in the sand: compassion is owed to people who can be framed as incapable; everyone else is expected to “earn” legitimacy through labor. That’s not just a policy preference, it’s a worldview. Jackson’s phrasing turns social support into a conditional gift rather than a shared civic infrastructure, and it does so by leaning on categories that feel self-evident (elderly, disabled) to make the hard edge (work requirements) sound like common sense.
The subtext is disciplinary. “Able-bodied” is doing heavy rhetorical work, implying that unemployment is primarily a matter of choice or character, not wages, layoffs, caregiving, or discrimination. “You should be working” reads like a moral imperative, not a realistic assessment of whether good jobs exist or whether they pay enough to live. The odd slip of “obligation too you” (likely “to you”) doesn’t soften the statement; it underscores how easily the language of duty can coexist with suspicion.
Context matters: Jackson, as a public servant in an era marked by welfare reform logic and “personal responsibility” politics, is speaking a familiar bipartisan dialect that treats government help as a last resort and tries to preempt the stereotype of the “undeserving” recipient. The result is a tidy, media-friendly sentence that reassures taxpayers while quietly narrowing the circle of who counts as worthy of public care.
The subtext is disciplinary. “Able-bodied” is doing heavy rhetorical work, implying that unemployment is primarily a matter of choice or character, not wages, layoffs, caregiving, or discrimination. “You should be working” reads like a moral imperative, not a realistic assessment of whether good jobs exist or whether they pay enough to live. The odd slip of “obligation too you” (likely “to you”) doesn’t soften the statement; it underscores how easily the language of duty can coexist with suspicion.
Context matters: Jackson, as a public servant in an era marked by welfare reform logic and “personal responsibility” politics, is speaking a familiar bipartisan dialect that treats government help as a last resort and tries to preempt the stereotype of the “undeserving” recipient. The result is a tidy, media-friendly sentence that reassures taxpayers while quietly narrowing the circle of who counts as worthy of public care.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work Ethic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alphonso
Add to List





