"I can give you a definite perhaps"
About this Quote
A “definite perhaps” is Hollywood’s most honest lie: a promise engineered to keep everyone moving without committing to anything that could later be used against you. Goldwyn, the legendary producer whose name became shorthand for mangled brilliance, compresses an entire industry’s power dynamic into three words. “Definite” flatters the listener with the feeling of progress and authority. “Perhaps” slips the handcuffs back on reality.
The intent is managerial, almost tactical. In the studio era, producers were the air-traffic controllers of egos, budgets, and schedules, forever negotiating between stars who wanted certainty and financiers who demanded guarantees. Goldwyn’s phrase functions as a pressure valve: it keeps talent hopeful, keeps deals warm, keeps meetings from ending in a hard no. It’s also a way to preserve leverage. If you say yes, you lose bargaining power. If you say no, you lose the relationship. So you say “definite perhaps” and let time do the dirty work.
The subtext is that decisiveness is often theater. Hollywood sells conviction on screen while surviving on ambiguity off it. Goldwyn’s accidental poetry exposes that contradiction: the entertainment machine runs on options, not vows, and on optimism that’s always one rewrite away from cancellation.
Context matters because Goldwyn wasn’t just a quipster; he was a producer building an empire in an era when moguls spoke in ultimatums and contracts. The joke lands because it’s not only funny - it’s a recognizable survival skill, inside and outside the industry, wherever people need to sound certain while staying unpinned.
The intent is managerial, almost tactical. In the studio era, producers were the air-traffic controllers of egos, budgets, and schedules, forever negotiating between stars who wanted certainty and financiers who demanded guarantees. Goldwyn’s phrase functions as a pressure valve: it keeps talent hopeful, keeps deals warm, keeps meetings from ending in a hard no. It’s also a way to preserve leverage. If you say yes, you lose bargaining power. If you say no, you lose the relationship. So you say “definite perhaps” and let time do the dirty work.
The subtext is that decisiveness is often theater. Hollywood sells conviction on screen while surviving on ambiguity off it. Goldwyn’s accidental poetry exposes that contradiction: the entertainment machine runs on options, not vows, and on optimism that’s always one rewrite away from cancellation.
Context matters because Goldwyn wasn’t just a quipster; he was a producer building an empire in an era when moguls spoke in ultimatums and contracts. The joke lands because it’s not only funny - it’s a recognizable survival skill, inside and outside the industry, wherever people need to sound certain while staying unpinned.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List
