"I cannot but be grieved to go from my native land, and especially from that part of it for whom and with whom I desired only to live; yet the dreadful apprehensions I have of what is coming upon this land may help to make me submissive to this providence, though more bitter"
About this Quote
The psychological hinge is "dreadful apprehensions". He doesn’t predict; he shudders. That vagueness is strategic. In a Scotland riven by post-Restoration persecution of Presbyterian dissenters, specificity could be incriminating, or simply too raw. Cargill was a Covenanter, later executed for defying the crown-aligned church settlement. The subtext is that the coming calamity is not abstract fate but state violence wearing legal clothing.
The phrase "submissive to this providence" performs a disciplined piety, the kind expected of a clergyman whose authority rests on spiritual steadiness. Yet he can’t quite sell the surrender: "though more bitter" lands like a confession that theology doesn’t anesthetize. It’s not resignation; it’s a costly self-command. The sentence becomes a small drama of conscience: loyalty to land and flock on one side, loyalty to God’s interpretation of events on the other. The power is in the tension he refuses to resolve.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nostalgia |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Cargill, Donald. (2026, January 17). I cannot but be grieved to go from my native land, and especially from that part of it for whom and with whom I desired only to live; yet the dreadful apprehensions I have of what is coming upon this land may help to make me submissive to this providence, though more bitter. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-cannot-but-be-grieved-to-go-from-my-native-land-65584/
Chicago Style
Cargill, Donald. "I cannot but be grieved to go from my native land, and especially from that part of it for whom and with whom I desired only to live; yet the dreadful apprehensions I have of what is coming upon this land may help to make me submissive to this providence, though more bitter." FixQuotes. January 17, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-cannot-but-be-grieved-to-go-from-my-native-land-65584/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"I cannot but be grieved to go from my native land, and especially from that part of it for whom and with whom I desired only to live; yet the dreadful apprehensions I have of what is coming upon this land may help to make me submissive to this providence, though more bitter." FixQuotes, 17 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/i-cannot-but-be-grieved-to-go-from-my-native-land-65584/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.







