"I cannot doubt that women will line up, like the men elected, with the groups whose political thinking and convictions are in accord with their own political convictions"
About this Quote
Rogers is trying to make women’s political participation sound boring - and that’s the point. Wrapped in the careful politeness of “I cannot doubt” is a strategic downshift: women entering electoral politics won’t detonate the party system, won’t create a new bloc, won’t threaten male incumbents with some mysterious “women’s vote.” They’ll “line up” the way men already do, folding into existing groups whose convictions match their own. It’s reassurance sold as principle.
The phrasing does quiet rhetorical work. “Like the men elected” positions male political behavior as the norm and women as the arriving cohort that must prove compatibility. The repetition of “political convictions” is almost defensive, as if she’s insisting - to skeptical colleagues and to the public - that women possess stable, legible ideology rather than mere sentiment or moral crusading. In an era when women were routinely cast as inherently nonpartisan, or as a single-issue moral force, Rogers argues for differentiation: women will not vote as women; they will vote as Republicans, Democrats, labor supporters, prohibition opponents, internationalists, isolationists.
Context matters: Rogers, a Republican congresswoman and one of the first women to hold a long House career, operated in a post-suffrage landscape still anxious about what enfranchised women would do. Her intent is pragmatic coalition-building. The subtext is an admission of constraint: entry into power often requires promising not to change the furniture. The irony is that even while she downplays women as a distinct political force, she’s asserting their full citizenship in the most establishment terms possible - ideology, affiliation, conviction.
The phrasing does quiet rhetorical work. “Like the men elected” positions male political behavior as the norm and women as the arriving cohort that must prove compatibility. The repetition of “political convictions” is almost defensive, as if she’s insisting - to skeptical colleagues and to the public - that women possess stable, legible ideology rather than mere sentiment or moral crusading. In an era when women were routinely cast as inherently nonpartisan, or as a single-issue moral force, Rogers argues for differentiation: women will not vote as women; they will vote as Republicans, Democrats, labor supporters, prohibition opponents, internationalists, isolationists.
Context matters: Rogers, a Republican congresswoman and one of the first women to hold a long House career, operated in a post-suffrage landscape still anxious about what enfranchised women would do. Her intent is pragmatic coalition-building. The subtext is an admission of constraint: entry into power often requires promising not to change the furniture. The irony is that even while she downplays women as a distinct political force, she’s asserting their full citizenship in the most establishment terms possible - ideology, affiliation, conviction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Edith
Add to List
