"I cannot help but think that great results would have been obtained had my views been thought better of; yet I am much inclined to accept the present condition as for the best"
About this Quote
Longstreet is doing something rarer than battlefield bravado: he’s writing a sentence that tries to survive history. The first clause is a quiet act of self-exoneration. “I cannot help but think” softens what is, underneath, a pointed claim: if they’d listened to me, we’d have done better. It’s the language of a man who knows the record is contested and wants credit without sounding like he’s begging for it. “Great results” is deliberately vague, a way to gesture toward victory without having to litigate tactics in public.
Then comes the turn that makes the line work: “yet I am much inclined to accept the present condition as for the best.” That’s resignation, but it’s also reputation management. Longstreet, Lee’s senior subordinate at Gettysburg, spent much of the postwar era cast by Lost Cause partisans as the convenient villain: the general who delayed, the man who “failed” Lee. After the war he compounded that hostility by aligning with Reconstruction and the Republican Party. So this sentence reads like a man threading a needle: asserting professional judgment while refusing to sound disloyal or bitter.
The subtext is emotional discipline. He’s signaling that he can live with ambiguity, even with unfairness, because clinging to alternate outcomes is corrosive. It’s also a subtle rebuttal to romanticized Confederate mythmaking. Longstreet isn’t sanctifying defeat; he’s domesticating it, pulling the war down from legend to the human scale of decisions, misreadings, and consequences that can’t be rewound.
Then comes the turn that makes the line work: “yet I am much inclined to accept the present condition as for the best.” That’s resignation, but it’s also reputation management. Longstreet, Lee’s senior subordinate at Gettysburg, spent much of the postwar era cast by Lost Cause partisans as the convenient villain: the general who delayed, the man who “failed” Lee. After the war he compounded that hostility by aligning with Reconstruction and the Republican Party. So this sentence reads like a man threading a needle: asserting professional judgment while refusing to sound disloyal or bitter.
The subtext is emotional discipline. He’s signaling that he can live with ambiguity, even with unfairness, because clinging to alternate outcomes is corrosive. It’s also a subtle rebuttal to romanticized Confederate mythmaking. Longstreet isn’t sanctifying defeat; he’s domesticating it, pulling the war down from legend to the human scale of decisions, misreadings, and consequences that can’t be rewound.
Quote Details
| Topic | Letting Go |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List






