"I divide all readers into two classes: those who read to remember and those who read to forget"
About this Quote
Phelps draws a bright line that’s less about readers than about the moral economy of reading. “Two classes” has the snap of a lecture-hall aphorism: tidy, binary, and intentionally provocative, the kind of taxonomy an educator uses to make students locate themselves. But the punch is in the reversal. We expect reading to be acquisitive, a respectable act of stocking the mind. Phelps makes room for its opposite: reading as erasure, as anesthesia, as a chosen temporary amnesia.
The subtext is a defense of pleasure and escape at a moment when American culture was turning literacy into a civic religion. As a prominent teacher and public intellectual in the late 19th and early 20th century, Phelps lived amid anxieties about “serious” books versus popular fiction, self-improvement versus entertainment. By framing forgetfulness as a legitimate motive, he quietly decriminalizes the so-called frivolous reader without fully surrendering the authority of the classroom. It’s permissive, but still supervisory: he grants the second category existence while keeping the first as the implied ideal.
The line also flatters both camps. The rememberers get discipline and status; the forgetters get relief, even salvation. And it hints at something darker: forgetting isn’t just leisure, it’s coping. Reading can be a technology for managing modernity’s pressures, a private room you can enter without permission. Phelps’s neat division works because it captures an old tension in one clean hinge: books as tools for building a self, and books as doors you walk through to stop being one for a while.
The subtext is a defense of pleasure and escape at a moment when American culture was turning literacy into a civic religion. As a prominent teacher and public intellectual in the late 19th and early 20th century, Phelps lived amid anxieties about “serious” books versus popular fiction, self-improvement versus entertainment. By framing forgetfulness as a legitimate motive, he quietly decriminalizes the so-called frivolous reader without fully surrendering the authority of the classroom. It’s permissive, but still supervisory: he grants the second category existence while keeping the first as the implied ideal.
The line also flatters both camps. The rememberers get discipline and status; the forgetters get relief, even salvation. And it hints at something darker: forgetting isn’t just leisure, it’s coping. Reading can be a technology for managing modernity’s pressures, a private room you can enter without permission. Phelps’s neat division works because it captures an old tension in one clean hinge: books as tools for building a self, and books as doors you walk through to stop being one for a while.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List


