"I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use"
About this Quote
Falconer’s line is a genteel but unmistakable act of defiance: a refusal to treat faith as a warrant for intellectual self-harm. The sentence is built like a courtroom argument, not a hymn. He starts by granting the premise his opponents want - the authority of “the same God” - then uses it as a lever. If God is the source of “sense, reason, and intellect,” it becomes incoherent to demand that believers “forgo their use.” The logic turns piety against anti-intellectual piety, making skepticism sound less like rebellion than basic consistency.
The subtext is that there are religious voices asking for exactly that forfeiture: to accept doctrine without scrutiny, to submit conscience to clerical or institutional certainty, to treat curiosity as corrosive. Falconer answers without flamboyance, but the politeness is strategic. “I do not feel obliged” frames the stance as personal conscience rather than open provocation; it’s Enlightenment rhetoric in its most socially survivable form. Even the triplet “sense, reason, and intellect” escalates from everyday perception to higher cognition, insisting the whole human toolkit is morally licensed.
Contextually, this sits neatly in the mid-18th century, when British culture is negotiating the aftershocks of scientific revolution and the rise of rational religion. As a poet, Falconer isn’t drafting a treatise; he’s distilling an era’s anxiety into a sentence that makes thinking feel like devotion. The real intent isn’t to dethrone God. It’s to dethrone the gatekeepers who claim God prefers you credulous.
The subtext is that there are religious voices asking for exactly that forfeiture: to accept doctrine without scrutiny, to submit conscience to clerical or institutional certainty, to treat curiosity as corrosive. Falconer answers without flamboyance, but the politeness is strategic. “I do not feel obliged” frames the stance as personal conscience rather than open provocation; it’s Enlightenment rhetoric in its most socially survivable form. Even the triplet “sense, reason, and intellect” escalates from everyday perception to higher cognition, insisting the whole human toolkit is morally licensed.
Contextually, this sits neatly in the mid-18th century, when British culture is negotiating the aftershocks of scientific revolution and the rise of rational religion. As a poet, Falconer isn’t drafting a treatise; he’s distilling an era’s anxiety into a sentence that makes thinking feel like devotion. The real intent isn’t to dethrone God. It’s to dethrone the gatekeepers who claim God prefers you credulous.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List







