"I do not see why man should not be just as cruel as nature"
About this Quote
There’s a cold, transactional logic in this line that makes it more dangerous than a rant: it tries to launder human choice through the alibi of “nature.” By posing cruelty as a reasonable imitation of the natural world, Hitler is doing rhetorical judo. He takes an observation people half-believe anyway - that nature is indifferent, violent, full of predation - and turns it into a moral permission slip. If nature is cruel, then cruelty isn’t a sin; it’s realism. Not ideology, but biology.
The intent is normalization. “I do not see why” frames brutality as merely common sense, the position of someone unburdened by sentimental ethics. The subtext is a rejection of modern moral constraints: compassion, rights, the idea that civilization exists to curb raw force. It’s also a subtle attack on empathy as weakness, a cornerstone of fascist style: invert the moral hierarchy so that mercy becomes decadence and violence becomes health.
Context matters because Hitler’s politics depended on this kind of pseudo-Darwinian story: society as a struggle of races, history as a sorting machine, extermination as “selection.” Nature, in this script, is not a complex ecosystem but a propaganda backdrop - stripped of cooperation, care, and interdependence. The line narrows nature to a single mood (cruelty) so that state violence can pose as inevitability.
The rhetorical trick is fatalistic: if cruelty is natural, resistance becomes unnatural. That’s how mass murder gets reframed as order.
The intent is normalization. “I do not see why” frames brutality as merely common sense, the position of someone unburdened by sentimental ethics. The subtext is a rejection of modern moral constraints: compassion, rights, the idea that civilization exists to curb raw force. It’s also a subtle attack on empathy as weakness, a cornerstone of fascist style: invert the moral hierarchy so that mercy becomes decadence and violence becomes health.
Context matters because Hitler’s politics depended on this kind of pseudo-Darwinian story: society as a struggle of races, history as a sorting machine, extermination as “selection.” Nature, in this script, is not a complex ecosystem but a propaganda backdrop - stripped of cooperation, care, and interdependence. The line narrows nature to a single mood (cruelty) so that state violence can pose as inevitability.
The rhetorical trick is fatalistic: if cruelty is natural, resistance becomes unnatural. That’s how mass murder gets reframed as order.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Adolf Hitler (Hourly History, 2016) modern compilationISBN: 9781537392912 · ID: E--dDwAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... I do not see why man should not be just as cruel as nature . " -Adolf Hitler After the U.S. stock market crashed in 1929 and the Great Depression began , the German people became less and less satisfied with their government . The new ... Other candidates (1) Adolf Hitler (Adolf Hitler) compilation41.3% ational freedom and liberty or why he should not be allowed a free hand in centr |
More Quotes by Adolf
Add to List











