"I don't feel we did wrong in taking this great country away from them. There were great numbers of people who needed new land, and the Indians were selfishly trying to keep it for themselves"
About this Quote
The line lands like a boot heel: blunt, unbothered, and dressed up as common sense. John Wayne isn’t trying to argue history so much as reinforce a myth - the frontier as a moral machine that turns conquest into “need,” and theft into nation-building. The phrasing does the heavy lifting. “This great country” is a rhetorical laundering cycle: once the land is framed as already-and-obviously “great,” the violence required to seize it becomes an unfortunate footnote. “Away from them” glides past the fact that “them” were nations with laws, agriculture, diplomacy, and sovereignty. The grammar itself performs erasure.
The real tell is “selfishly.” It flips the moral axis so completely that refusal to surrender your home becomes a character flaw. That inversion is the subtext: settler entitlement presented as necessity, Indigenous self-defense recast as hoarding. “Great numbers of people who needed new land” leans on a crowd as a kind of ethical alibi - if enough settlers want something, the wanting becomes justification. It’s a logic of expansion where demographics replace rights.
Context matters because Wayne wasn’t just an actor; he was an emblem. His screen persona - stoic, righteous, Westward-facing - trained audiences to read American expansion as destiny with good posture. Spoken in the mid-20th century, this isn’t a relic of 1870s thinking; it’s a modern defense of the old story at the moment civil rights, Red Scare nationalism, and Hollywood’s Western factory were all shaping what “America” was allowed to remember. The intent is less to persuade skeptics than to reassure believers: the mythology is intact, and the victims are still being asked to play villains.
The real tell is “selfishly.” It flips the moral axis so completely that refusal to surrender your home becomes a character flaw. That inversion is the subtext: settler entitlement presented as necessity, Indigenous self-defense recast as hoarding. “Great numbers of people who needed new land” leans on a crowd as a kind of ethical alibi - if enough settlers want something, the wanting becomes justification. It’s a logic of expansion where demographics replace rights.
Context matters because Wayne wasn’t just an actor; he was an emblem. His screen persona - stoic, righteous, Westward-facing - trained audiences to read American expansion as destiny with good posture. Spoken in the mid-20th century, this isn’t a relic of 1870s thinking; it’s a modern defense of the old story at the moment civil rights, Red Scare nationalism, and Hollywood’s Western factory were all shaping what “America” was allowed to remember. The intent is less to persuade skeptics than to reassure believers: the mythology is intact, and the victims are still being asked to play villains.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | John Wayne interview, Playboy magazine (1971) — contains the cited remark about taking the country from Native Americans. |
More Quotes by John
Add to List



