"I don't know how to sit outside myself and test against a hypothetical self who stayed home"
About this Quote
Restlessness is rarely just wanderlust; it is a refusal to grant the “version of me who didn’t” any authority. Gunn’s line turns a common modern compulsion into an epistemological problem: he cannot “sit outside myself,” cannot stage the neat little counterfactual experiment where a stable observer compares two timelines. The phrasing matters. “Test against” borrows the language of measurement, as if a life could be A/B tested, as if the self were a lab sample. Gunn punctures that fantasy with a blunt admission of limits: there is no clean control group for a lived life.
The subtext is both defensive and quietly mournful. The hypothetical self “who stayed home” isn’t just a missed itinerary; it’s the imagined moral accountant who might claim the traveler’s pleasures are evasions, or that movement is a cover for fear of stillness. Gunn won’t even grant that figure a seat at the table. The line reads like a preemptive strike against regret and against the genre of self-improvement that feeds on alternate selves: the fitter you, the calmer you, the you who made the other choice.
Context sharpens it. Gunn’s work moves between discipline and appetite, control and exposure, with a life shaped by migration (England to the U.S.), queer desire, and the aftershocks of the AIDS era. In that terrain, “staying home” can imply safety, conformity, even survival. The sentence doesn’t romanticize risk, but it insists on the irreversibility of lived experience: you can narrate your choices, you can’t litigate them against an imaginary witness.
The subtext is both defensive and quietly mournful. The hypothetical self “who stayed home” isn’t just a missed itinerary; it’s the imagined moral accountant who might claim the traveler’s pleasures are evasions, or that movement is a cover for fear of stillness. Gunn won’t even grant that figure a seat at the table. The line reads like a preemptive strike against regret and against the genre of self-improvement that feeds on alternate selves: the fitter you, the calmer you, the you who made the other choice.
Context sharpens it. Gunn’s work moves between discipline and appetite, control and exposure, with a life shaped by migration (England to the U.S.), queer desire, and the aftershocks of the AIDS era. In that terrain, “staying home” can imply safety, conformity, even survival. The sentence doesn’t romanticize risk, but it insists on the irreversibility of lived experience: you can narrate your choices, you can’t litigate them against an imaginary witness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thom
Add to List






