"I don't know what happens if they get bin Laden. I'm much more interested in what happens if they don't get bin Laden"
About this Quote
Fisk’s line is a pinprick to the post-9/11 mood that treated bin Laden like a master key: find him, turn the lock, history clicks back into place. The blunt opener, “I don’t know,” isn’t humility so much as refusal. He won’t play the reassuring game of teleology, the comforting narrative that one man’s capture can explain a war, justify an occupation, or cleanse a policy.
The real force sits in the pivot: “much more interested.” Fisk drags attention away from the manhunt-as-morality-play and toward the machinery built around it. If they don’t get him, what then? The question exposes how “failure” can be politically useful. An elusive enemy sustains emergency powers, keeps budgets swollen, extends military footprints, and protects leaders from the messy work of defining victory. The subtext is that bin Laden, alive or simply unaccounted for, functions as a floating signifier: proof that the threat remains, that the campaign must continue, that dissent can be framed as naivete.
As a journalist who spent decades in the Middle East chronicling Western intervention, Fisk is also signaling skepticism about whose story gets told. The chase centers Western agency and drama; the aftermath centers consequences on the ground: civilians, blowback, radicalization, and the corrosion of civil liberties at home. The quote works because it swaps suspense for audit. It asks readers to judge not the symbolic endpoint of a hunt, but the incentives and collateral damage created when a war needs a fugitive to stay narratively alive.
The real force sits in the pivot: “much more interested.” Fisk drags attention away from the manhunt-as-morality-play and toward the machinery built around it. If they don’t get him, what then? The question exposes how “failure” can be politically useful. An elusive enemy sustains emergency powers, keeps budgets swollen, extends military footprints, and protects leaders from the messy work of defining victory. The subtext is that bin Laden, alive or simply unaccounted for, functions as a floating signifier: proof that the threat remains, that the campaign must continue, that dissent can be framed as naivete.
As a journalist who spent decades in the Middle East chronicling Western intervention, Fisk is also signaling skepticism about whose story gets told. The chase centers Western agency and drama; the aftermath centers consequences on the ground: civilians, blowback, radicalization, and the corrosion of civil liberties at home. The quote works because it swaps suspense for audit. It asks readers to judge not the symbolic endpoint of a hunt, but the incentives and collateral damage created when a war needs a fugitive to stay narratively alive.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List



