Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Ralph Vaughan Williams

"I don't know whether I like it, but it is what I meant"

About this Quote

A composer admitting he might not even like his own work, yet insisting it hits the target, is a quiet act of defiance against the whole romance of “inspiration.” Vaughan Williams draws a hard line between taste and intention: the piece isn’t a mood ring for the artist’s current feelings, it’s an engineered statement. That split matters in a field where “beauty” and “preference” can become tyrannical, pressuring composers to sand down edges until they’re palatable. He’s saying the job is not to charm himself; it’s to realize an inner necessity.

The subtext is discipline, almost austerity. “I don’t know” signals honest uncertainty, not coyness, and it’s directed inward: the creator can be the least reliable critic of the thing he just made. “But it is what I meant” reasserts authorship in the only way that counts - not “it pleases me,” not “it will please you,” but “it is accurate.” Accuracy becomes the ethical standard.

In context, this fits Vaughan Williams’s stance as a modern British composer who absorbed folk materials, rejected flashy continental virtuosity, and kept a wary distance from fashionable avant-gardes. His music often aims for plainspoken power rather than polish. The line also reads like a rebuttal to critics and conductors: you can debate whether it “works,” but you can’t pretend it’s accidental. Whatever the listener hears, the composer’s intent isn’t up for negotiation.

Quote Details

TopicMusic
SourceHelp us find the source
More Quotes by Ralph Add to List
Ralph Vaughan Williams: Intention Over Liking
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

England Flag

Ralph Vaughan Williams (October 12, 1872 - August 26, 1958) was a Composer from England.

2 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Alice Cooper, Musician
Alice Cooper