"I don't really know what is shocking. When you tell the story of a man who is beheaded, you have to show how they cut off his head. If you don't, it's like telling a dirty joke and leaving out the punch line"
About this Quote
Polanski’s line isn’t defending gore for gore’s sake; it’s defending authorship. He frames “shock” as a moving target, a squeamish label audiences use when they don’t want to admit what a story is actually about. Beheading, in his formulation, isn’t an abstract plot point but an irreversible act of power, and cinema’s job is to make that irreversibility felt. The dirty-joke analogy is deliberately crass: it drags high-minded debates about “taste” down to mechanics. Set up, release. If you dodge the release, you’re not being ethical, you’re being evasive.
The subtext is a provocation aimed at moral gatekeeping and censorship. Polanski implies that sanitization is its own kind of lie: it lets viewers enjoy the drama without paying the emotional price. He’s also staking a claim for realism as honesty, even when that realism offends. That’s a familiar posture in postwar European art cinema, where violence on screen often functions as a rebuttal to societies eager to varnish their own brutality.
Context matters because Polanski’s career is steeped in narratives where violence isn’t spectacle but fate: from Knife in the Water’s tension to Macbeth’s blood-soaked paranoia and The Pianist’s historical atrocity. The quote reads like a director’s manifesto for refusing the tasteful cutaway. Coming from Polanski, it also lands uncomfortably close to his broader public controversies, sharpening the question he tries to sidestep: when does “showing the head” become less about truth and more about control over what the audience is allowed to look away from?
The subtext is a provocation aimed at moral gatekeeping and censorship. Polanski implies that sanitization is its own kind of lie: it lets viewers enjoy the drama without paying the emotional price. He’s also staking a claim for realism as honesty, even when that realism offends. That’s a familiar posture in postwar European art cinema, where violence on screen often functions as a rebuttal to societies eager to varnish their own brutality.
Context matters because Polanski’s career is steeped in narratives where violence isn’t spectacle but fate: from Knife in the Water’s tension to Macbeth’s blood-soaked paranoia and The Pianist’s historical atrocity. The quote reads like a director’s manifesto for refusing the tasteful cutaway. Coming from Polanski, it also lands uncomfortably close to his broader public controversies, sharpening the question he tries to sidestep: when does “showing the head” become less about truth and more about control over what the audience is allowed to look away from?
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Roman
Add to List







