"I encountered among my comrades the most varied human traits, from frankness to reserve, from goodness, uprightness and kindness, to brutality and baseness"
About this Quote
Brandes writes like a man taking inventory after a moral storm, and the ledger won’t balance. The sentence is built as a corridor of contrasts: “from frankness to reserve” feels almost social, the sort of temperament difference you notice in a salon. Then he pivots, hard, into ethics: “goodness, uprightness and kindness” set against “brutality and baseness.” The effect is deliberate whiplash. He’s not reporting quirky personalities; he’s mapping how quickly the human register slides from manners into violence.
As a critic, Brandes is famous for asking literature to face modern life without consolation. Here, that critical temperament becomes a wartime or political memory of comradeship stripped of romance. “Among my comrades” is the pressure point: comrades are supposed to be bound by shared purpose, even shared virtue. Brandes refuses that comforting myth. The group does not ennoble the individual; it simply concentrates humanity in all its contradictions. That’s the subtext: solidarity is not a moral guarantee, and proximity doesn’t purify.
The list format matters. By stacking virtues in threes, he gives goodness a rhetorical fullness, then counters with two blunt nouns that land like verdicts. “Baseness” in particular is a critic’s word: it judges, it classifies, it won’t hide behind psychology. Brandes is signaling an intent to tell the truth about collective life, even when it sabotages the genre expectations of comradeship narratives. The line reads like a warning to readers and to himself: don’t confuse a cause with character.
As a critic, Brandes is famous for asking literature to face modern life without consolation. Here, that critical temperament becomes a wartime or political memory of comradeship stripped of romance. “Among my comrades” is the pressure point: comrades are supposed to be bound by shared purpose, even shared virtue. Brandes refuses that comforting myth. The group does not ennoble the individual; it simply concentrates humanity in all its contradictions. That’s the subtext: solidarity is not a moral guarantee, and proximity doesn’t purify.
The list format matters. By stacking virtues in threes, he gives goodness a rhetorical fullness, then counters with two blunt nouns that land like verdicts. “Baseness” in particular is a critic’s word: it judges, it classifies, it won’t hide behind psychology. Brandes is signaling an intent to tell the truth about collective life, even when it sabotages the genre expectations of comradeship narratives. The line reads like a warning to readers and to himself: don’t confuse a cause with character.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Georg
Add to List






