"I feel very confident that Americans flying in the air are safe and that only under the most dire of circumstances would our pilots ever even request permission to do that"
About this Quote
Shelton’s line is a masterclass in bureaucratic reassurance that accidentally spotlights the very danger it’s trying to downplay. The opening clause, “I feel very confident,” is less evidence than posture: a senior military voice performing calm for a public that wants certainty. Confidence becomes the product, not the conclusion. Then comes the oddly specific image, “Americans flying in the air,” a phrase so literal it sounds like it’s tiptoeing around the real subject - Americans flying in the air near other Americans, in tense airspace, amid rules of engagement designed to prevent catastrophe.
The sentence’s real work happens in the conditional: “only under the most dire of circumstances.” That’s a familiar Pentagon incantation, meant to bracket fear inside an extreme hypothetical. But “dire” is elastic, and Shelton knows it. The more amorphous the threshold, the easier it is to promise restraint while preserving operational latitude.
Then the kicker: “request permission to do that.” The phrase “do that” functions like a verbal blackout curtain, implying an action too grim or politically radioactive to name plainly. It suggests a context where pilots might be asked to take extraordinary measures - the kind that, once said out loud, turns “safety” into a morally loaded tradeoff. Shelton’s intent is to project control: protocols exist, authority is centralized, decisions won’t be impulsive. The subtext is that the unimaginable is already on the table, and the institution is trying to get ahead of the story by framing it as rare, regulated, and reluctant.
The sentence’s real work happens in the conditional: “only under the most dire of circumstances.” That’s a familiar Pentagon incantation, meant to bracket fear inside an extreme hypothetical. But “dire” is elastic, and Shelton knows it. The more amorphous the threshold, the easier it is to promise restraint while preserving operational latitude.
Then the kicker: “request permission to do that.” The phrase “do that” functions like a verbal blackout curtain, implying an action too grim or politically radioactive to name plainly. It suggests a context where pilots might be asked to take extraordinary measures - the kind that, once said out loud, turns “safety” into a morally loaded tradeoff. Shelton’s intent is to project control: protocols exist, authority is centralized, decisions won’t be impulsive. The subtext is that the unimaginable is already on the table, and the institution is trying to get ahead of the story by framing it as rare, regulated, and reluctant.
Quote Details
| Topic | Military & Soldier |
|---|
More Quotes by Hugh
Add to List
