"I felt that the studio recording process makes you stand still too long"
About this Quote
There is a quiet rebellion baked into that complaint: the studio asks a singer to become a specimen. For Kiri Te Kanawa, whose artistry was forged in the big, breathing ecology of opera, “stand still too long” isn’t just about boredom or stiff legs. It’s about what happens when a living performance gets dissected into takes, fixes, and microscopic self-surveillance.
The intent reads as a defense of momentum. Onstage, opera is athletic storytelling: you ride an orchestra, a room, a character’s pulse. The body knows things the mind can’t schedule. Studio work, by contrast, encourages a kind of hyper-control that can flatten the very risks that make a voice feel human. Te Kanawa’s line is pointedly physical. She doesn’t say the process is “less authentic” or “too artificial”; she says it immobilizes you. That’s the subtext: artistry requires motion - emotional, musical, even literal - and the studio rewards stillness, repeatability, and polish.
Context matters because Te Kanawa came of age when recordings were both prestige objects and commercial expectations, especially for star classical singers. The industry wanted definitive versions, not fleeting nights. Her phrasing pushes back on the fetish of perfection: the idea that music should be scrubbed until it’s timeless. She’s reminding us that timelessness can be another word for lifelessness, and that the “best” performance might be the one that can’t be frozen without losing its heat.
The intent reads as a defense of momentum. Onstage, opera is athletic storytelling: you ride an orchestra, a room, a character’s pulse. The body knows things the mind can’t schedule. Studio work, by contrast, encourages a kind of hyper-control that can flatten the very risks that make a voice feel human. Te Kanawa’s line is pointedly physical. She doesn’t say the process is “less authentic” or “too artificial”; she says it immobilizes you. That’s the subtext: artistry requires motion - emotional, musical, even literal - and the studio rewards stillness, repeatability, and polish.
Context matters because Te Kanawa came of age when recordings were both prestige objects and commercial expectations, especially for star classical singers. The industry wanted definitive versions, not fleeting nights. Her phrasing pushes back on the fetish of perfection: the idea that music should be scrubbed until it’s timeless. She’s reminding us that timelessness can be another word for lifelessness, and that the “best” performance might be the one that can’t be frozen without losing its heat.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Kiri
Add to List
