"I hate the idea of causes, and if I had to choose between betraying my country and betraying my friend, I hope I should have the guts to betray my country"
About this Quote
Forster lobs this line like a genteel hand grenade into the parlor of patriotism. The surface provocation - betray your country? - is the point: he wants to make the reflexive loyalty of “causes” feel not noble but suspect, a kind of moral outsourcing. “Causes” are abstract, clean-edged, easy to applaud from a distance. Friends are messy, particular, and inconvenient. By forcing the choice, Forster doesn’t glamorize treason so much as indict the way nations and movements recruit our consciences with grand nouns.
The subtext is anti-idolatry. Forster had watched early 20th-century Europe turn ideals into machinery: war propaganda, imperial certainty, and later the totalizing demands of fascism and communism. In that climate, the individual gets crushed between flags and slogans. His preference for “betraying my country” isn’t a policy proposal; it’s a defense of private ethics against public hysteria, insisting that real decency happens at human scale.
The phrase “I hope I should have the guts” matters as much as the heresy. It admits fear and social cost: the hardest betrayal is often of your tribe, the people who tell you you’re righteous. Forster’s wit is that he frames loyalty to a friend as the braver choice, flipping the usual moral hierarchy. The line doubles as a warning to liberals, too: if your politics requires you to harden your heart toward someone concrete, your “cause” may be doing exactly what it claims to fight.
The subtext is anti-idolatry. Forster had watched early 20th-century Europe turn ideals into machinery: war propaganda, imperial certainty, and later the totalizing demands of fascism and communism. In that climate, the individual gets crushed between flags and slogans. His preference for “betraying my country” isn’t a policy proposal; it’s a defense of private ethics against public hysteria, insisting that real decency happens at human scale.
The phrase “I hope I should have the guts” matters as much as the heresy. It admits fear and social cost: the hardest betrayal is often of your tribe, the people who tell you you’re righteous. Forster’s wit is that he frames loyalty to a friend as the braver choice, flipping the usual moral hierarchy. The line doubles as a warning to liberals, too: if your politics requires you to harden your heart toward someone concrete, your “cause” may be doing exactly what it claims to fight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Betrayal |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by M. Forster
Add to List









