"I have a tendency to say yes to a script or no to a script. Not yes based on a rewrite"
About this Quote
Macy’s line has the clipped, dry finality of someone who’s spent decades watching Hollywood turn conviction into “notes.” The joke is in the blunt binary: yes or no, period. He’s not pretending scripts are sacred literature; he’s insisting that his job begins with what’s on the page, not with the comforting fantasy that the page will someday become the page he wishes he’d read.
The intent is practical and a little defiant. Actors are constantly asked to commit not to a story but to a promise: a producer’s promise that the third act will get fixed, a director’s promise that the character will deepen, a star’s promise that the dialogue will stop sounding like placeholder text. Macy refuses that speculative market. “Not yes based on a rewrite” is him pricing in the truth that rewrites often arrive late, diluted by committee, or aimed at solving problems that were structural all along. If the script doesn’t work now, the production will spend months trying to out-run that fact.
There’s also an ego-free professionalism hiding in the rigidity. Macy isn’t saying he can’t handle imperfect material; he’s saying he won’t gamble his time on other people’s follow-through. Coming from an actor associated with grounded, morally complicated characters, it reads like craft discipline: choose the foundation, not the scaffolding. In an industry addicted to development limbo, his binary is a small act of self-preservation and a quiet critique of how often “we’ll fix it in the rewrite” really means “we’ll fix it later, if we ever have to.”
The intent is practical and a little defiant. Actors are constantly asked to commit not to a story but to a promise: a producer’s promise that the third act will get fixed, a director’s promise that the character will deepen, a star’s promise that the dialogue will stop sounding like placeholder text. Macy refuses that speculative market. “Not yes based on a rewrite” is him pricing in the truth that rewrites often arrive late, diluted by committee, or aimed at solving problems that were structural all along. If the script doesn’t work now, the production will spend months trying to out-run that fact.
There’s also an ego-free professionalism hiding in the rigidity. Macy isn’t saying he can’t handle imperfect material; he’s saying he won’t gamble his time on other people’s follow-through. Coming from an actor associated with grounded, morally complicated characters, it reads like craft discipline: choose the foundation, not the scaffolding. In an industry addicted to development limbo, his binary is a small act of self-preservation and a quiet critique of how often “we’ll fix it in the rewrite” really means “we’ll fix it later, if we ever have to.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List



