Skip to main content

Life & Wisdom Quote by Antonio Porchia

"I have been my own disciple and my own master. And I have been a good disciple but a bad master"

About this Quote

Self-reliance is supposed to be the clean, modern ideal: no gurus, no gatekeepers, just you becoming you. Porchia punctures that fantasy with a paradox that lands like a small confession. To be "my own disciple and my own master" sounds empowering until he adds the twist: he has obeyed himself well, but governed himself badly. The line exposes how easily autonomy turns into a closed loop where the student is diligent and the teacher is indulgent, erratic, or cruel.

Porchia's genius is in the asymmetry. A "good disciple" implies humility, attention, consistency: the capacity to learn. A "bad master" implies failed leadership: poor judgment, shifting standards, punishments that don't teach, permissions that aren't earned. When both roles live inside one person, discipline becomes slippery. You can follow your own rules and still choose the wrong rules. You can work hard and still be misled by the authority in your head.

The subtext is psychological before it's philosophical. It's an admission that the self isn't a unified sovereign; it's a committee with power struggles. Porchia, writing in aphorisms that feel like pared-down spiritual notes without the comforting sermon, turns inward and finds not enlightenment but administrative failure. The context matters: a poet of fragments and distilled insights, he distrusts grand systems. This sentence argues that the hardest tyranny to overthrow is the one that signs its own decrees.

Quote Details

TopicSelf-Discipline
SourceHelp us find the source
More Quotes by Antonio Add to List
I have been my own disciple and my own master by Antonio Porchia
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

Antonio Porchia

Antonio Porchia (November 13, 1886 - November 9, 1968) was a Poet from Italy.

26 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Natalie Clifford Barney, Author