"I have been sworn against by perjured and wicked people"
About this Quote
A man already halfway to the gallows doesn’t bother with nuance. “I have been sworn against by perjured and wicked people” is Captain William Kidd’s tight, defensive pivot from deeds to testimony: don’t look at what I did, look at who’s talking about it. The verb choice matters. “Sworn against” turns the courtroom into a kind of ambush, suggesting not evidence but orchestrated betrayal. “Perjured” is legal language with a knife in it, an accusation that the system itself has been contaminated; “wicked” widens the charge from procedure to morality, casting his accusers as not merely wrong but corrupt in their souls.
The line’s intent is practical: to delegitimize witnesses and salvage the only currency left to him, credibility. Kidd isn’t arguing innocence so much as arguing rigging. That’s smart because his career sat in a gray zone: privateering licensed by the Crown, piracy condemned by it, the difference often determined by politics and timing. Once the winds shifted in London, Kidd became useful as a public example - proof that the state could “clean up” the seas while quietly protecting better-connected profiteers.
The subtext is the old cry of the scapegoat, but with an operator’s precision. He implies a conspiracy without naming names, inviting listeners to fill in the blanks with elites, rivals, and anxious officials. In a world where maritime violence was both policy and crime, Kidd’s complaint exposes an uncomfortable truth: justice can hinge less on actions than on who gets to swear, and who gets believed.
The line’s intent is practical: to delegitimize witnesses and salvage the only currency left to him, credibility. Kidd isn’t arguing innocence so much as arguing rigging. That’s smart because his career sat in a gray zone: privateering licensed by the Crown, piracy condemned by it, the difference often determined by politics and timing. Once the winds shifted in London, Kidd became useful as a public example - proof that the state could “clean up” the seas while quietly protecting better-connected profiteers.
The subtext is the old cry of the scapegoat, but with an operator’s precision. He implies a conspiracy without naming names, inviting listeners to fill in the blanks with elites, rivals, and anxious officials. In a world where maritime violence was both policy and crime, Kidd’s complaint exposes an uncomfortable truth: justice can hinge less on actions than on who gets to swear, and who gets believed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List





