"I have deserved neither so much honor or so much disgrace"
About this Quote
Corneille’s line lands like a perfectly weighted curtain drop: not an apology, not a boast, but a refusal to play the public’s binary game. “Neither so much honor nor so much disgrace” is calibrated humility with a blade in it. He’s not denying that he’s been praised or blamed; he’s questioning the scale. The word “so” does the real work, implying that the crowd’s judgment is not just wrong but wildly disproportionate.
As a dramatist in 17th-century France, Corneille lived inside systems that made reputations volatile: court patronage, religious scrutiny, and an emerging critical culture that treated plays like political events. After the uproar around Le Cid and the Académie française’s policing of “rules,” he became a symbol others could use - either as the genius who elevated French theater or the offender who bent decorum. This sentence reads like an artist trying to wrestle his identity back from a culture that turns creators into moral fables.
The subtext is especially modern: the speaker sees how honor and disgrace are often less about merit than about usefulness. Praise can be a way of conscripting you; condemnation can be a way of disciplining you. Corneille’s neat symmetry exposes that shared mechanism. He insists on a middle space where human work is messy, imperfect, and real - and where the audience’s need for heroes and villains is the most theatrical thing onstage.
As a dramatist in 17th-century France, Corneille lived inside systems that made reputations volatile: court patronage, religious scrutiny, and an emerging critical culture that treated plays like political events. After the uproar around Le Cid and the Académie française’s policing of “rules,” he became a symbol others could use - either as the genius who elevated French theater or the offender who bent decorum. This sentence reads like an artist trying to wrestle his identity back from a culture that turns creators into moral fables.
The subtext is especially modern: the speaker sees how honor and disgrace are often less about merit than about usefulness. Praise can be a way of conscripting you; condemnation can be a way of disciplining you. Corneille’s neat symmetry exposes that shared mechanism. He insists on a middle space where human work is messy, imperfect, and real - and where the audience’s need for heroes and villains is the most theatrical thing onstage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by Pierre
Add to List
