"I have known many who could not when they would, for they had not done it when they could"
About this Quote
Regret is rarely about wanting too little; it is about training too late. Rabelais turns that knife with a sentence that looks like a moral maxim but behaves like a diagnosis. The line pivots on two tiny words - would and could - and exposes how quickly freedom expires. People “could” act when circumstances, health, youth, money, time, or courage were available. They didn’t. Later they “would” act, but the capacity has leaked away: the body stiffens, obligations calcify, appetites dull, opportunities close, and the will itself gets out of practice.
The subtext is less “seize the day” than “habits are fate.” Rabelais implies that ability is not a permanent possession; it’s a muscle. Neglect it and you don’t merely miss a chance, you lose the instrument that makes future choices possible. That’s why the line feels unsentimental: it doesn’t console with destiny or bad luck. It pins the loss on a very human pattern - postponement dressed up as prudence.
Context matters. As a Renaissance cleric with a satirist’s eye (and the author of Gargantua and Pantagruel), Rabelais was suspicious of pious procrastination: the idea that one can delay reform, learning, or virtue until a cleaner, safer moment arrives. His theology-tinged cynicism lands here as practical ethics. Your later good intentions are not a credit account; they’re often just proof that you squandered your earlier powers.
The subtext is less “seize the day” than “habits are fate.” Rabelais implies that ability is not a permanent possession; it’s a muscle. Neglect it and you don’t merely miss a chance, you lose the instrument that makes future choices possible. That’s why the line feels unsentimental: it doesn’t console with destiny or bad luck. It pins the loss on a very human pattern - postponement dressed up as prudence.
Context matters. As a Renaissance cleric with a satirist’s eye (and the author of Gargantua and Pantagruel), Rabelais was suspicious of pious procrastination: the idea that one can delay reform, learning, or virtue until a cleaner, safer moment arrives. His theology-tinged cynicism lands here as practical ethics. Your later good intentions are not a credit account; they’re often just proof that you squandered your earlier powers.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Gargantua and Pantagruel — Francois Rabelais. Line appears in English translations of Rabelais's Gargantua and Pantagruel, often rendered: "I have known many that could not when they would, for they had not done it when they could." (edition/page varies) |
More Quotes by Francois
Add to List








