"I have known war as few men now living know it. It's very destructiveness on both friend and foe has rendered it useless as a means of settling international disputes"
About this Quote
MacArthur opens by staking exclusive authority: "I have known war as few men now living know it". It's not humility; it's a credential check, a way of locking the room before the argument even begins. Coming from a man synonymous with 20th-century American militarism, the move lands with extra voltage. The subtext is: I am not a pacifist by temperament, and that is precisely why you should take this seriously.
Then he pivots to the most quietly radical word in the line: "useless". He doesn't call war evil, or immoral, or tragic - all claims that invite counterclaims about necessity. He calls it inefficient, broken as a tool. That's a soldier's heresy: war framed not as a moral failure but as a strategic anachronism. "Very destructiveness on both friend and foe" flattens the old romance of clean victories; even the winners come home gutted. The phrase "friend and foe" also widens the blast radius beyond the battlefield, hinting at civilians, infrastructure, economies, and the long tail of trauma.
Context matters. MacArthur lived through industrial slaughter in World War I, orchestrated the island-hopping attrition of World War II, and confronted the new arithmetic of nuclear weapons and total war. In that world, "settling international disputes" by force stops looking like problem-solving and starts looking like mutual liquidation. The intent isn't to sentimentalize peace; it's to warn that modern war no longer produces the kind of political clarity states claim to want. It produces ruins - and then calls that a resolution.
Then he pivots to the most quietly radical word in the line: "useless". He doesn't call war evil, or immoral, or tragic - all claims that invite counterclaims about necessity. He calls it inefficient, broken as a tool. That's a soldier's heresy: war framed not as a moral failure but as a strategic anachronism. "Very destructiveness on both friend and foe" flattens the old romance of clean victories; even the winners come home gutted. The phrase "friend and foe" also widens the blast radius beyond the battlefield, hinting at civilians, infrastructure, economies, and the long tail of trauma.
Context matters. MacArthur lived through industrial slaughter in World War I, orchestrated the island-hopping attrition of World War II, and confronted the new arithmetic of nuclear weapons and total war. In that world, "settling international disputes" by force stops looking like problem-solving and starts looking like mutual liquidation. The intent isn't to sentimentalize peace; it's to warn that modern war no longer produces the kind of political clarity states claim to want. It produces ruins - and then calls that a resolution.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Douglas
Add to List
