"I have never acknowledged the difference between serious music and light music. There is only good music and bad music"
About this Quote
Weill’s line isn’t a kumbaya plea for “all genres matter.” It’s a provocation aimed at the gatekeepers who treat taste like a border checkpoint. Coming from a composer who moved between opera house prestige and the supposedly “low” world of popular theater, it’s also self-defense: a way to preempt the charge that crossing categories is artistic slumming. He refuses the moral hierarchy baked into “serious” versus “light,” where one is framed as rigorous and the other as disposable. His blunt binary - good/bad - flips the conversation from social status to craft.
The subtext is class anxiety. “Serious music” has long been a proxy for education, money, and institutional approval, while “light music” gets coded as commercial, feminine, immigrant, urban, or simply too pleasurable to be respectable. Weill, a German-Jewish modernist who fled Nazism and rebuilt his career in America, knew how quickly culture becomes a sorting mechanism. In that context, the quote reads like an artist refusing to let the labels of one country’s conservatories or another country’s Broadway producers decide what counts.
It works because it’s both idealistic and cutting. Idealistic in insisting that aesthetic judgment should be portable across styles; cutting in suggesting that the “serious/light” split is a polite alibi for snobbery. Weill’s real claim is tougher: if your “serious” piece can’t move people, or your “light” song can’t withstand scrutiny, the category won’t save you.
The subtext is class anxiety. “Serious music” has long been a proxy for education, money, and institutional approval, while “light music” gets coded as commercial, feminine, immigrant, urban, or simply too pleasurable to be respectable. Weill, a German-Jewish modernist who fled Nazism and rebuilt his career in America, knew how quickly culture becomes a sorting mechanism. In that context, the quote reads like an artist refusing to let the labels of one country’s conservatories or another country’s Broadway producers decide what counts.
It works because it’s both idealistic and cutting. Idealistic in insisting that aesthetic judgment should be portable across styles; cutting in suggesting that the “serious/light” split is a polite alibi for snobbery. Weill’s real claim is tougher: if your “serious” piece can’t move people, or your “light” song can’t withstand scrutiny, the category won’t save you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Kurt Weill; cited on Wikiquote (Kurt Weill page) — wording often given as: "There is no such thing as 'serious' and 'light' music. There is only good music and bad music." |
More Quotes by Kurt
Add to List
