"I have noticed even people who claim everything is predestined, and that we can do nothing to change it, look before they cross the road"
About this Quote
Fatalism collapses the moment a bus is involved. Hawking’s line is funny because it’s petty in the best way: it drags an abstract metaphysical posture down to street level, where rubber meets rhetoric. Anyone can sound serene about predestination in a seminar or on social media. Put them at a curb, and their body votes for agency.
The intent is a clean jab at the performative certainty of hard determinism when it’s used as a worldview rather than a technical claim about physics. Hawking isn’t refuting causality or the deep puzzles of free will; he’s exposing the everyday hypocrisy of people who treat “it’s all fated” as an all-purpose alibi. The subtext is that beliefs reveal themselves less in what we proclaim than in what we do when stakes appear. Looking both ways is a micro-ritual of responsibility: an admission that prediction, choice, and risk management matter.
Contextually, Hawking lived at the intersection of cosmic determinism and human fragility. As a physicist, he was comfortable with a universe governed by laws; as a public intellectual, he also understood how quickly “science-y” ideas get converted into moral permission slips. The road-crossing image is perfect because it’s mundane, universal, and unglamorous: it doesn’t ask you to solve the free will debate, just to notice that even the loudest determinist still checks for traffic. In that small glance, philosophy becomes behavioral science, and the argument ends with a raised eyebrow.
The intent is a clean jab at the performative certainty of hard determinism when it’s used as a worldview rather than a technical claim about physics. Hawking isn’t refuting causality or the deep puzzles of free will; he’s exposing the everyday hypocrisy of people who treat “it’s all fated” as an all-purpose alibi. The subtext is that beliefs reveal themselves less in what we proclaim than in what we do when stakes appear. Looking both ways is a micro-ritual of responsibility: an admission that prediction, choice, and risk management matter.
Contextually, Hawking lived at the intersection of cosmic determinism and human fragility. As a physicist, he was comfortable with a universe governed by laws; as a public intellectual, he also understood how quickly “science-y” ideas get converted into moral permission slips. The road-crossing image is perfect because it’s mundane, universal, and unglamorous: it doesn’t ask you to solve the free will debate, just to notice that even the loudest determinist still checks for traffic. In that small glance, philosophy becomes behavioral science, and the argument ends with a raised eyebrow.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List











