"I have the same sense of the power and virtue of knowledge that some people get from a religious background"
About this Quote
Gilbert frames knowledge not as a tool but as a moral force - something you can believe in, not just use. The line is deft because it borrows religion's emotional architecture (awe, discipline, conversion, community) while swapping out revelation for evidence. He isn't mocking faith; he's acknowledging what faith does well: it supplies a durable sense of purpose and a vocabulary for virtue. Then he quietly claims that science can generate the same internal gravity.
The intent reads partly autobiographical and partly polemical. As a molecular biologist who helped define late-20th-century genetics, Gilbert came of age when science was selling itself as both progress and ethos: the postwar lab as secular monastery, the genome as a new text to be read. Saying he has a "religious background" level of conviction in knowledge positions him as someone motivated by reverence rather than mere careerism. It also asks the listener to take scientists seriously as people with values, not just procedures.
The subtext is a cultural negotiation. In societies where religion often claims monopoly on virtue, Gilbert sidesteps a direct fight and instead offers an equivalence: you can be ethically animated by empiricism. The phrase "power and virtue" is doing heavy lifting - "power" nods to technology and predictive control, while "virtue" insists that knowing more can make you better, or at least more responsible.
It's also a warning label. Treating knowledge like faith can produce courage and clarity; it can also tempt dogmatism. Gilbert's phrasing flirts with that tension, which is why it lands.
The intent reads partly autobiographical and partly polemical. As a molecular biologist who helped define late-20th-century genetics, Gilbert came of age when science was selling itself as both progress and ethos: the postwar lab as secular monastery, the genome as a new text to be read. Saying he has a "religious background" level of conviction in knowledge positions him as someone motivated by reverence rather than mere careerism. It also asks the listener to take scientists seriously as people with values, not just procedures.
The subtext is a cultural negotiation. In societies where religion often claims monopoly on virtue, Gilbert sidesteps a direct fight and instead offers an equivalence: you can be ethically animated by empiricism. The phrase "power and virtue" is doing heavy lifting - "power" nods to technology and predictive control, while "virtue" insists that knowing more can make you better, or at least more responsible.
It's also a warning label. Treating knowledge like faith can produce courage and clarity; it can also tempt dogmatism. Gilbert's phrasing flirts with that tension, which is why it lands.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List





