"I just met someone who read Gone With the Wind 62 times for exactly that same reason. She couldn't bear that it wasn't real. She wanted to live in it"
About this Quote
Compulsion disguises itself as taste here, and Bechdel nails that sleight of hand with a storyteller’s scalpel. The detail is almost comic in its extremity: 62 times. Not “loved it,” not “reread it,” but a ritualized return that edges into self-preservation. The number is doing cultural work; it’s the quantifiable version of an unquantifiable ache, a receipt for longing.
Bechdel’s real target isn’t Gone With the Wind so much as the psychic bargain certain narratives offer: if you keep consuming them, they’ll stop being stories and start behaving like shelter. “She couldn’t bear that it wasn’t real” is a devastating diagnosis of fandom-as-grief. It’s also a quiet critique of what kind of “real” is being mourned. The book’s plantation romance is a famously ornate lie about the Old South; wanting to live in it suggests not just escapism, but a desire for a world where cruelty is aestheticized and consequences can be edited away. Bechdel doesn’t sermonize; she lets the reader feel the discomfort of recognizing how seductive that editing can be.
As a cartoonist and memoirist, Bechdel is attuned to how people build private mythologies out of mass culture. The line carries a double-edge: empathy for someone clawing toward a livable reality, and suspicion of the fantasy’s politics. It’s a portrait of reading not as enrichment, but as a kind of voluntary haunting.
Bechdel’s real target isn’t Gone With the Wind so much as the psychic bargain certain narratives offer: if you keep consuming them, they’ll stop being stories and start behaving like shelter. “She couldn’t bear that it wasn’t real” is a devastating diagnosis of fandom-as-grief. It’s also a quiet critique of what kind of “real” is being mourned. The book’s plantation romance is a famously ornate lie about the Old South; wanting to live in it suggests not just escapism, but a desire for a world where cruelty is aestheticized and consequences can be edited away. Bechdel doesn’t sermonize; she lets the reader feel the discomfort of recognizing how seductive that editing can be.
As a cartoonist and memoirist, Bechdel is attuned to how people build private mythologies out of mass culture. The line carries a double-edge: empathy for someone clawing toward a livable reality, and suspicion of the fantasy’s politics. It’s a portrait of reading not as enrichment, but as a kind of voluntary haunting.
Quote Details
| Topic | Book |
|---|
More Quotes by Alison
Add to List




