"I know from my constituency what is going on. Doctors that are told, begged, by mothers, 'Please don't write down that my child as asthma. Please lie and say it's bronchitis, because if you write down asthma, when my child turns 18 or 20 and has to get his or her own insurance, it will be a pre-existing condition.'"
About this Quote
Boxer isn’t trying to win an abstract policy argument here; she’s staging a moral ambush. The power move is the pivot from Washington-speak to a kitchen-table confession: “mothers” begging doctors to “please lie.” That plea is the point. When a system makes ordinary people ask professionals to falsify medical records, the scandal is no longer partisan or technocratic. It’s behavioral. It changes how citizens act, what they fear, and what they’re willing to compromise.
The rhetoric is courtroom-specific: she builds credibility (“I know from my constituency”), then introduces an anecdote that functions as evidence and indictment at once. Notice the specificity of “asthma” versus “bronchitis.” These aren’t exotic diagnoses; they’re common childhood conditions. The subtext is that the pre-existing condition regime doesn’t just punish the chronically ill; it weaponizes the most routine vulnerability. A child’s wheeze becomes a future financial sentence.
Her choice of verbs is doing the heavy lifting. “Told, begged” underscores powerlessness, while “Please lie” spotlights the ethical inversion: the doctor becomes an accomplice, the parent becomes a supplicant, the medical chart becomes a legal trap. Boxer is also quietly indicting the private insurance incentives that make documentation dangerous. The message to colleagues is clear: if you defend the status quo, you’re defending a world where honesty is a luxury and health care is managed like a criminal record.
The rhetoric is courtroom-specific: she builds credibility (“I know from my constituency”), then introduces an anecdote that functions as evidence and indictment at once. Notice the specificity of “asthma” versus “bronchitis.” These aren’t exotic diagnoses; they’re common childhood conditions. The subtext is that the pre-existing condition regime doesn’t just punish the chronically ill; it weaponizes the most routine vulnerability. A child’s wheeze becomes a future financial sentence.
Her choice of verbs is doing the heavy lifting. “Told, begged” underscores powerlessness, while “Please lie” spotlights the ethical inversion: the doctor becomes an accomplice, the parent becomes a supplicant, the medical chart becomes a legal trap. Boxer is also quietly indicting the private insurance incentives that make documentation dangerous. The message to colleagues is clear: if you defend the status quo, you’re defending a world where honesty is a luxury and health care is managed like a criminal record.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Barbara
Add to List
