"I know that John Adams has had a very hard time directing French ensembles"
About this Quote
A deadpan name-drop that lands like a slipped beat: John Adams, the brand-name American minimalist, cast not as a titan but as a harried professional stuck wrangling French orchestras. Gavin Bryars knows exactly what he is doing here. The line reads like backstage gossip, but it’s also a small, precise critique of how musical authority actually gets negotiated: not in manifestos, but in rehearsal rooms where taste, tradition, and ego collide.
The phrase “very hard time” is doing quiet work. Bryars doesn’t say Adams was misunderstood, or that the music is too radical. He frames it as “directing,” a verb that implies leadership, persuasion, and managerial patience - the unglamorous labor that sits behind the myth of the visionary composer. And “French ensembles” is not incidental. It cues a whole cultural script: France’s strong institutional traditions, a historically guarded relationship with American musical exports, and the prestige politics that can turn collaboration into a power struggle. Minimalism, with its plainspoken surfaces and American confidence, can read as an aesthetic of inevitability; French orchestral culture often prizes a different kind of rhetorical sophistication. The friction is almost baked in.
Bryars, a composer who’s long operated in the borderlands between experimental and classical worlds, is also positioning himself. He’s not flexing superiority; he’s signaling insider knowledge and sympathy for the messy, human side of “serious music.” The subtext: genius doesn’t exempt you from diplomacy, and cultural capital doesn’t travel as smoothly as the scores do.
The phrase “very hard time” is doing quiet work. Bryars doesn’t say Adams was misunderstood, or that the music is too radical. He frames it as “directing,” a verb that implies leadership, persuasion, and managerial patience - the unglamorous labor that sits behind the myth of the visionary composer. And “French ensembles” is not incidental. It cues a whole cultural script: France’s strong institutional traditions, a historically guarded relationship with American musical exports, and the prestige politics that can turn collaboration into a power struggle. Minimalism, with its plainspoken surfaces and American confidence, can read as an aesthetic of inevitability; French orchestral culture often prizes a different kind of rhetorical sophistication. The friction is almost baked in.
Bryars, a composer who’s long operated in the borderlands between experimental and classical worlds, is also positioning himself. He’s not flexing superiority; he’s signaling insider knowledge and sympathy for the messy, human side of “serious music.” The subtext: genius doesn’t exempt you from diplomacy, and cultural capital doesn’t travel as smoothly as the scores do.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Gavin
Add to List



