"I like working with other people but I'm not a songwriter, I'm a producer"
About this Quote
There is a quiet line in Josh Silver's quote that hits like a boundary set in a studio doorway: collaboration, yes; authorship, no. In pop culture, we love the myth of the lone genius with a guitar and a diary. Silver is rejecting that mythology without rejecting creativity. "I like working with other people" signals social ease and a taste for the messy, collective parts of music-making. The pivot, "but", is the real move: he draws a clean map of where his identity lives.
Calling himself "a producer" is not modesty; it's power, just a different kind. Producers don't have to write the lyric to decide which lyric survives the take. They shape tempo, texture, dynamics, tone, and the emotional architecture that makes a song land. The subtext is: my authorship is structural. I'm not chasing the spotlight of the songwriter credit; I'm building the room where the spotlight works.
There's also a pragmatic cultural context here. In modern music, songwriting is a legal category as much as an artistic one: publishing splits, royalties, liner-note politics. "I'm not a songwriter" can be an ethical stance (don't claim credit you didn't earn) and a strategic one (avoid credit disputes) while still asserting essential contribution.
The quote reads like a corrective to how audiences rank creative labor. Silver isn't diminishing himself; he's insisting that making records is not secondary to writing songs. It's a different craft, with its own ego discipline and its own authority.
Calling himself "a producer" is not modesty; it's power, just a different kind. Producers don't have to write the lyric to decide which lyric survives the take. They shape tempo, texture, dynamics, tone, and the emotional architecture that makes a song land. The subtext is: my authorship is structural. I'm not chasing the spotlight of the songwriter credit; I'm building the room where the spotlight works.
There's also a pragmatic cultural context here. In modern music, songwriting is a legal category as much as an artistic one: publishing splits, royalties, liner-note politics. "I'm not a songwriter" can be an ethical stance (don't claim credit you didn't earn) and a strategic one (avoid credit disputes) while still asserting essential contribution.
The quote reads like a corrective to how audiences rank creative labor. Silver isn't diminishing himself; he's insisting that making records is not secondary to writing songs. It's a different craft, with its own ego discipline and its own authority.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Josh
Add to List


