"I live for playing live. All my records are live, since After the Gold Rush, with the exception of Trans and the vocals on Landing on Water"
About this Quote
Neil Young is basically telling you he doesn’t trust the studio to tell the truth. “I live for playing live” isn’t just a preference for loud amps and sweaty rooms; it’s a declaration of values. The live setting is where risk lives: tempos wobble, guitars bleed, audiences push back. That friction is the point. Young’s best work has always sounded like it might fall apart at any moment, and he treats that near-collapse as authenticity, not a flaw.
The sly flex is in the second sentence: “All my records are live...” He’s reframing the whole idea of a record. Most artists use the studio as a place to perfect; Young uses it as a place to document. Even when you’re hearing an “album,” he wants you to picture an event, a performance captured with minimal cosmetic surgery. The anchor point, After the Gold Rush, matters: it’s the moment he solidified a voice that could be intimate and ragged at once, like a private confession overheard through a cracked door.
Then come the exceptions: Trans and the vocals on Landing on Water. Those aren’t random footnotes; they’re neon signs. Trans is his famous detour into synthetic, processed sound - a deliberate embrace of mediation, technology, and alienation. Naming it as an exception frames it as concept, not betrayal. Even rebels have rules, and Young’s rule is simple: if the recording doesn’t feel like a lived moment, it better have a damn good reason.
The sly flex is in the second sentence: “All my records are live...” He’s reframing the whole idea of a record. Most artists use the studio as a place to perfect; Young uses it as a place to document. Even when you’re hearing an “album,” he wants you to picture an event, a performance captured with minimal cosmetic surgery. The anchor point, After the Gold Rush, matters: it’s the moment he solidified a voice that could be intimate and ragged at once, like a private confession overheard through a cracked door.
Then come the exceptions: Trans and the vocals on Landing on Water. Those aren’t random footnotes; they’re neon signs. Trans is his famous detour into synthetic, processed sound - a deliberate embrace of mediation, technology, and alienation. Naming it as an exception frames it as concept, not betrayal. Even rebels have rules, and Young’s rule is simple: if the recording doesn’t feel like a lived moment, it better have a damn good reason.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Neil
Add to List


