"I may be kindly, I am ordinarily gentle, but in my line of business I am obliged to will terribly what I will at all"
About this Quote
Kindness, Catherine implies, is a private preference; power is a public discipline. The sentence is built like a velvet glove pulled slowly over a fist. She starts with character references the court could admire: kindly, gentle, ordinarily. Then she pivots on the blunt little word but, and suddenly we are not talking about temperament but trade. “My line of business” is the chilling demystification: ruling isn’t a divine aura or a romantic destiny, it’s a job with deliverables. The job, she admits, requires a specific kind of violence that begins before armies move or prisons fill: in the will itself.
The key phrase is “will terribly what I will at all.” Not “do terribly,” but will terribly. Catherine is describing sovereignty as an internal posture: once a decision is made, hesitation becomes cruelty of another kind. Mercy can be a personal inclination, yet governance, especially in an empire stitched together by patronage, paranoia, and distance, demands decisions that land like edicts, not conversations. She’s also offering a prophylactic against sentimental critiques: if you want a gentle ruler, you are asking for an unstable one.
In context, this is the voice of an Enlightenment-branded autocrat who corresponded with philosophers while tightening the mechanics of control. The quote’s genius is its candor. It doesn’t excuse brutality; it frames it as the cost of coherence. Catherine isn’t confessing a flaw so much as staking a claim: the state cannot be run on softness alone, and she refuses to apologize for the hardness that keeps her throne, and Russia, intact.
The key phrase is “will terribly what I will at all.” Not “do terribly,” but will terribly. Catherine is describing sovereignty as an internal posture: once a decision is made, hesitation becomes cruelty of another kind. Mercy can be a personal inclination, yet governance, especially in an empire stitched together by patronage, paranoia, and distance, demands decisions that land like edicts, not conversations. She’s also offering a prophylactic against sentimental critiques: if you want a gentle ruler, you are asking for an unstable one.
In context, this is the voice of an Enlightenment-branded autocrat who corresponded with philosophers while tightening the mechanics of control. The quote’s genius is its candor. It doesn’t excuse brutality; it frames it as the cost of coherence. Catherine isn’t confessing a flaw so much as staking a claim: the state cannot be run on softness alone, and she refuses to apologize for the hardness that keeps her throne, and Russia, intact.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Catherine
Add to List









