"I never force myself to be devout except when I feel so inspired, and never compose hymns of prayers unless I feel within me real and true devotion"
About this Quote
Schubert speaks as a composer who treats sacred feeling as a condition, not an assignment. Devotion cannot be summoned on command; it must arrive, and when it does, it authorizes the work. That stance reflects a Romantic insistence on authenticity. For Schubert, emotion is not ornament but foundation, and especially when addressing the sacred, any counterfeit tenderness or forced piety would be a betrayal both of art and of faith.
The remark gains weight in light of his life and output. A Catholic in early 19th-century Vienna, he wrote several Masses, many tied to the parish of Lichtental where he grew up. These pieces, like the Mass in G or the Mass in A-flat, often balance luminous simplicity with sudden harmonic turns that feel like private prayer made public. He was prolific and disciplined, often composing daily, yet he draws a clear line: routine can guide technique, but it cannot produce genuine devotion. Sacred music receives a different standard than an exercise in counterpoint or a salon song. He will not use the language of prayer unless the inner voice is present.
There is a quiet irony that one of his most famous melodies, universally known as "Ave Maria", began as a setting of a secular text by Walter Scott. Over time, the melody invited prayer from listeners anyway, suggesting that sincerity can inhabit music beyond its textual origin. The point remains: authentic feeling, not assignment, is what gives religious music its persuasive force.
The statement also resists institutional expectations. Composers often wrote to order for church and court; Schubert, largely independent, asserts a personal ethic that values truth of feeling over obligation. Listeners can hear the difference between devotional music made from the outside in and music that rises from an inward spark. By waiting for real and true devotion, he protects the integrity of both his craft and the subject, trusting that when inspiration arrives, the work will carry a living breath that no amount of effort can counterfeit.
The remark gains weight in light of his life and output. A Catholic in early 19th-century Vienna, he wrote several Masses, many tied to the parish of Lichtental where he grew up. These pieces, like the Mass in G or the Mass in A-flat, often balance luminous simplicity with sudden harmonic turns that feel like private prayer made public. He was prolific and disciplined, often composing daily, yet he draws a clear line: routine can guide technique, but it cannot produce genuine devotion. Sacred music receives a different standard than an exercise in counterpoint or a salon song. He will not use the language of prayer unless the inner voice is present.
There is a quiet irony that one of his most famous melodies, universally known as "Ave Maria", began as a setting of a secular text by Walter Scott. Over time, the melody invited prayer from listeners anyway, suggesting that sincerity can inhabit music beyond its textual origin. The point remains: authentic feeling, not assignment, is what gives religious music its persuasive force.
The statement also resists institutional expectations. Composers often wrote to order for church and court; Schubert, largely independent, asserts a personal ethic that values truth of feeling over obligation. Listeners can hear the difference between devotional music made from the outside in and music that rises from an inward spark. By waiting for real and true devotion, he protects the integrity of both his craft and the subject, trusting that when inspiration arrives, the work will carry a living breath that no amount of effort can counterfeit.
Quote Details
| Topic | Prayer |
|---|
More Quotes by Franz
Add to List
