"I never guess. It is a shocking habit destructive to the logical faculty"
About this Quote
A line like this pretends to be a simple rule of thumb, but it’s really a manifesto for an entire way of moving through the world. “I never guess” is less personal modesty than a performance of discipline: the speaker casts himself as someone who refuses the cozy shortcut of intuition, even when intuition would be faster, friendlier, more human. The punch is in the Victorian sting of “shocking habit,” a moralistic phrase normally reserved for vice. Guessing isn’t merely inaccurate here; it’s a kind of self-harm, an indulgence that corrodes the mind.
Doyle’s context matters: he’s writing at the height of a culture intoxicated by scientific authority, classification, and the promise that careful observation could make the messy world legible. Sherlock Holmes (the voice this line is typically associated with) embodies that era’s fantasy of pure rational mastery. The sentence works because it’s both aspirational and slightly ridiculous. “Destructive to the logical faculty” sounds like a medical diagnosis for a social sin, turning cognition into a fragile organ that must be protected from contamination.
The subtext is also defensive. By declaring guessing taboo, the speaker quietly grants how tempting it is - and how often other people rely on it. It flatters the reader with a standard they can admire, while also warning: once you start letting hunches pose as evidence, you won’t notice when you stop thinking altogether. Doyle makes logic feel not just useful, but ethically urgent.
Doyle’s context matters: he’s writing at the height of a culture intoxicated by scientific authority, classification, and the promise that careful observation could make the messy world legible. Sherlock Holmes (the voice this line is typically associated with) embodies that era’s fantasy of pure rational mastery. The sentence works because it’s both aspirational and slightly ridiculous. “Destructive to the logical faculty” sounds like a medical diagnosis for a social sin, turning cognition into a fragile organ that must be protected from contamination.
The subtext is also defensive. By declaring guessing taboo, the speaker quietly grants how tempting it is - and how often other people rely on it. It flatters the reader with a standard they can admire, while also warning: once you start letting hunches pose as evidence, you won’t notice when you stop thinking altogether. Doyle makes logic feel not just useful, but ethically urgent.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List
